Organised by: EXARC & Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń (PL)
Integrating the Archaeological Experiment into a Multidisciplinary Science and its Popularisation
Scientific observations conducted by the outstanding Toruń citizen Nicolaus Copernicus led to the breaking of dogmas and solving one of the greatest mysteries in the history of humankind; namely, they answered the question about the actual position of our planet in the solar system. We adhere to this scientific approach in the city of Copernicus also today, seeing our archaeological experiments as an essential and integral part of multi-faceted studies on human prehistory and history.
The medieval city of Toruń is on the Vistula River in north-central Poland and a UNESCO World Heritage Site. It is located halfway between the Polish capital of Warsaw and the major port city of Gdańsk. Toruń is well-connected with other Polish and European cities.
By organising the Experimental Archaeology Conference (#EAC13) in our city Toruń, we would like to honour the unique role that experimental archaeology plays in such a modern, scientific and interdisciplinary approach to research to reconstruct life in the past. Therefore, we invite to participate in the conference, particularly those who conduct experiments closely related to archaeological and historical sources and verify their results using modern scientific methods and research tools. We are very curious how the knowledge obtained in this way is applied to archaeological studies and how it functions in the context of other findings, e.g., the results of palaeobiological, physicochemical, or environmental studies. Is it compatible or contradicting them?
However, we also do not forget, of course, about the fundamental goal of each scientific study, which is to popularise the knowledge gained as a result of it in the broader group of recipients. Therefore, to participate in the conference, we would also invite those who base their educational activities on premises rooted in professional archaeological research or other scientific studies. Such action is, in our opinion, essential, being the only way to build a vision of the past in modern society that corresponds to reality, without simplifications and falsifications, unfortunately often served by the mass culture media.
Registration Fee (on site participation)
Conference | 2 Days (1-2 May, 2023) | 1 Day (1st OR 2nd May, 2023) |
Regular (EXARC member, cat. 1 & 2) | € 100 | € 60 |
Student (EXARC member, cat. 1 & 2) | € 65 | € 40 |
Regular (non-EXARC or EXARC cat. 3) | € 140 | € 80 |
Student (non-EXARC or EXARC cat. 3) | € 95 | € 50 |
Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń staff / students | € 25 | € 25 |
Dinner | |
Monday night, May 1st, 2023 | € 30 |
Tuesday night, May 1st, 2023 (to arrange by yourself, at own expense) | n/a |
Excursions
We offer two excursions. One is a preconference guided tour through Toruń on Sunday afternoon (30 April). The other one takes place on May 3rd and takes you to Biskupin. Please check the excursions here.
Excursion 1: Muzeum Archeologiczne w Biskupinie Wednesday, May 3, 2023 (whole day), incl bus, entry, coffee and lunch Maximum number of Participants: 55 |
€ 40 |
Excursion 2: Guided Tour Toruń Sunday, April 30, 2023, 15:00h Maximum number of Participants: 35 |
For free (registration is required) |
Sponsors
Sponsors for the online sessions With your contribution, you help us air lectures & presentations. Please check the Sponsors' page for more information. |
€ 250 per hour |
Discord
Attending the #EAC13 Conference online is free and open access to all. It will be live streamed on YouTube via EXARCs official channel. Here you can follow each session, and ask questions in our Q&A. Speakers will be present to answer a number of these questions. Besides that, we have a free and open access "plus" platform, Discord. Here you can interact with one another in thematic text and audio channels. You can see these as breakout rooms.
Updated, April 25, 2023
All times are local time to Poland, i.e. CEST
Arriving Day - Sunday April 30, 2023
15:00h Guided tour through Toruń (free of charge, on registration)
We will meet at the parking bay at CKK Jordanki al. Solidarności 1, location Google Maps
Day 1 - Monday, May 1, 2023
TIP: Virtual walk in Collegium Humanisticum (the building, where we will have the conference) Virtual walk in Institute of Archaeology, Niclaus Copernicus University, Toruń |
Location: Collegium Humanisticum at Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, ul. Bojarskiego 1, 87-100 Toruń
(location Google Maps: https://goo.gl/maps/dmcTdekSJ87nCfTE9)
All presentations are on the spot and online, except evening session 5, which is online only. Please click here for abstracts.
8:00 | Registration | |
9:00 | Session: Welcome Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1NEtBHvHRVvsBD8OnzfSGzC |
|
9:00 | Welcome from Nicolaus Copernicus University, by Dean of the Faculty of History at NCU in Toruń, prof. dr hab. Stanisław Roszak Location: Room 009 |
|
Welcome from Nicolaus Copernicus University, by Dr hab. Grzegorz Osipowicz and Dr Justyna Orłowska (PL) Location: Room 009 |
||
Welcome from EXARC Location: Room 009 |
||
9:10 | Opening: Experimental Archaeology In Poland – History, Science and Education by Grzegorz Osipowicz, Justyna Orłowska, Justyna Kuriga (PL) Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw |
|
10:00 | Session 1.A Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1Nt405ZGgwdZMBIGFCsUvor |
Session 1.B Location: Room 008 Moderator: Giovanna Fregni Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1N8VbpvmdHI5sl00knpMvEX |
Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here | Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here | |
Paper 1.A.1: Disentangling the Complexity of the Gönnersdorf Plaquette Engravings: manual and robotic Experiments by Jérôme Robitaille, Lisa-Elen Meyering (DE) |
Paper 1.B.1: Iron Age Combustion Structures in the Western Mediterranean: an Approach from the Experimental Archaeology by Maria-Carme Belarte, María Pastor Quiles, Marta Portillo, Carme Saorin, Marta Mateu Sagués, Alessandra Pecci, Sílvia Vila, Josep Pou, Georgina Castells, Jordi Morer, Joaquín Fernández (ES) |
|
Paper 1.A.2: Experimental Reproduction of Traces Documented on Middle Palaeolithic Bone Retouchers from the Ciemna Cave by Piotr Werens, Damian Stefański, Katarzyna Zarzecka-Szubińska (PL) |
Paper 1.B.2: Experimental Cremations in Different burning Environments: Open versus semi-close Pyre in Crete, Greece by Yannis Chatzikonstantinou, Evangelia Kiriatzi, Sevasti Triantaphyllou (GR) |
|
Paper 1.A.3: What Did Neanderthals Wear on Their Feet? An Experimental Archaeological Investigation of Neanderthal Footwear by Phoebe Baker, Andy Needham (UK) |
Paper 1.B.3: Reconstructing the Pyrotechnological Development of The Harappans Using Ethnographic Parallels in The Region of Ghaggar, India by Garima Singh (IN) |
|
Paper 1.A.4: Late Palaeolithic Ornamentation in Experiments: A Case of an Ornamented Artefact from Birów Mountain in South Poland by Tomasz Płonka, Marcin Diakowski (PL) |
Poster 1.B.4: Bone Tubes from Corded Ware Culture as Sound Generators/Musical Instruments. Reconstructing Manufacture and Usage by Dominika Tokarz (PL) |
|
10:55 | Coffee Break | |
11:15 | Session 2.A Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1PDOwxkwrLtTgL3sbmjD-39 |
Session 2.B Location: Room 008 Moderator: Giovanna Fregni Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1NGroW_b4z5EsaO5rNGek55 |
Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here | Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here | |
Sponsor: the Polish National Science Centre (NCN), project no. 2021/43/B/HS3/00500, entitled "Life and death written in bones" |
Sponsor: the Polish National Science Centre (NCN), project no. 2021/43/B/HS3/00500, entitled "Life and death written in bones" |
|
Paper 2.A.1: Turning Roman Columns on the Lathe: Experimental Approach and Archaeological Analysis of Artefacts from North-Eastern Gaul by Nicolas Revert & Brice Brigaud (FR) |
Paper 2.B.1: Phytoliths Reference Collection from the Experimental Perspective by Aleksandra Gawron-Szymczyk (PL) |
|
Paper 2.A.2: Reconstructing the Workshop from Viborg Søndersø: New Insights into Viking Wooden Building Construction by Jim Glazzard, Aimée Little, Steve Ashby (UK) |
Paper 2.B.2: Was It Always Leather? by Sally Herriett (UK) |
|
Paper 2.A.3: All You Need is Mud: How Open-Air Museums can Champion Sustainability in the Built Environment by Caroline Nicolay (UK) |
Paper 2.B.3: Traceology on Prehistoric Wooden Artefacts, is it Possible? by Grzegorz Osipowicz (PL), Justyna Orłowska (PL), Giedrė Piličiauskienė (LT), Gytis Piličiauskas (LT) |
|
Paper 2.A.4: Experimental Archeology as a Tool for Understanding the Cultural Changes of Bone Artifacts from four Brazilian Early Holocene Sites by Gabriela S. Mingatos, Mercedes Okumura (BR) |
Paper 2.B.4: Prehispanic Woodcrafts in the Canary Islands: technical Processes and experimental Program by Paloma Vidal-Matutano, Antoni Palomo, Dorota Wojtczak, Amelia Rodríguez, Idaira Brito-Abrante, Jared Carballo-Pérez, Kiara Ortega, Salvador Pardo-Gordó (ES) |
|
Poster 2.A.5: The Saka Barrow Building Technology: Experimenting with Turf and Logs by Ulan Umitkaliev, Diana Ayapova (KZ) |
Paper 2.B.5: Smash and Burn: Apple Seed Damage Characteristics for the Identification of Actions and Processes Performed on Apples by Jessi Berndt (DE) |
|
Poster 2.A.6: Identification of Plants in Mud Building Materials. An Experimental Archaeology Project by María Pastor Quiles (ES) |
||
12:30 | Questions & Answers Sessions 1.A and 2.A | Questions & Answers Sessions 1.B and 2.B |
13:15 | Lunch | |
14:30 | Session 3.A Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1OzexDSD7jp9sw2k5aHF4NR |
Session 3.B Location: Room 008 Moderator: Giovanna Fregni Playlist:https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1NEPTYzrZZ94sk0fDsr2DzS |
Sponsor: University College Dublin Cultural Landscapes and Social Spaces (ClaSS) Earth Institute Strategic Project 2022 |
Sponsor: University College Dublin Introducing UCD centre for Experimental Archaeology and Material culture (CEAMC) |
|
Paper 3.A.1: The late Viking Age Warship, Skuldelev 5: exploring old Interpretations with a new Reconstruction by Martin R. Dael, Tríona Sørensen (DK) |
Paper 3.B.1: Archaeological Experiments in the Study of the Textile Economy of the Wielbark Culture by Magdalena Przymorska-Sztuczka (PL) |
|
Paper 3.A.2: What can be Difficult in Building the Boat? The Experiments Released During the First International Camp of Experimental Archaeology, Toruń 2021 by Justyna Orłowska, Justyna Kuriga, Grzegorz Osipowicz (PL) |
Paper 3.B.2: Teeth, Fibre-Crafts, and Health: What Experimental Archaeology can tell us about the Textile Workers of the Ancient World by Anita Radini (IE) |
|
Paper 3.A.3: The Gislinge Boat Open Source Project: from Experimental Archaeology to Outreach by Tríona Sørensen (DK) |
Paper 3.B.3: Z for warp, S for weft. Investigating Choices of Yarn in English Medieval Textiles by Kat Stasinska (UK) |
|
Paper 3.A.4: The Bronze Age Chariot of the Sintashta-Petrovka Period by Igor Chechushkov (US), Ivan Semyan (AR) |
Paper 3.B.4: How Warped the Loom. An Examination of Loom Traces on Woven Cloth by Jo Duke (CA) |
|
Paper 3.A.5: Experimental Archaeological Observation on the Base of Chinese Terracotta Xiao Flute Player Figurine (202 BC-220 AD) by Bangcheng Tang (CN) |
Paper 3.B.5: Tarquinia’s Tablets: A Reconstruction of Tablet Weaving Patterns found on the Tomb of the Triclinium’s Left Wall by Richard Joseph Palmer (US) |
|
15:50 | Questions & Answers Session 3.A | Questions & Answers Session 3.B |
16:15 | Coffee Break | |
16:30 | Session 4 Location: Room 009 Moderator: Giovanna Fregni Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1O5ohG418wgq4DT0Ag9XOTm |
|
Sponsor: John Kiernan The EXARC Experimental Archaeology Award |
||
Introduction Archaeological Open-Air Museums in Ukraine | ||
Round Table SUN including Presentations and Discussion https://exarc.net/ukrainesupport |
||
18:00 | Free Time | |
19:00 | Dinner (Optional - at own expense - 30 EUR, need to register & pay in advance) Restauracja Gospoda Pod Modrym Fartuchem & Krajina Piva Pub Rynek Nowomiejski 8, 87-100 Toruń location Google Maps |
20:00 | Session 5 ONLINE ONLY Moderator: Phoebe Baker Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1MsecqCRwTgOUl0i-aK5Dc8 |
Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here |
|
Introduction: EXARC and its Opportunities | |
Paper 5.1: Searching for ‘the true Colors’ of the Eastern European Chalcolithic painting Techniques, through experimental and archaeometrical Approaches by Felix-Adrian Tencariu, Ana Drob, Maria-Cristina Ciobanu (RO) |
|
Paper 5.2: Not just for Food: processing Unio sp. Shells at the Gumelnița Communities (mill. V BC) by Monica Mărgărit, Valentin Radu (RO) |
|
Paper 5.3: Experimental Beadmaking with Roman Glass by Sue Heaser (UK) |
|
Paper 5.4: Rediscovering the Process of Making Type 2 & Type 3 Aiglets by Gerald A. Livings (US) |
|
Paper 5.5: Experimental Tattooing and Analysis of Preserved Skin Markings on Human Mummies by Aaron Deter-Wolf (US), Danny Riday (NZ), Maya Sialuk Jacobsen (GL) |
|
Paper 5.6: Exploring Rock Art Application Techniques: An Experimental Approach To Study Rock Paintings from La Candelaria (Catamarca, Argentina) by Matías Landino, Eugenia Ahets Etcheberry, Lucas Gheco, Marcos R. Gastaldi, Marcos Tascon, Marcos Quesada3, Fernando Marte (AR) |
|
21:40 | Questions & Answers Session 5 |
Day 2 - Tuesday, May 2, 2023
Location: Collegium Humanisticum at Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, ul. Bojarskiego 1, 87-100 Toruń
(location google maps: https://goo.gl/maps/dmcTdekSJ87nCfTE9)
All presentations are on the spot and online, except evening session 10, which is online only. Please click here for abstracts.
8:00 | Registration | |
9:00 | Session 6 Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1N5njdaILea4hCIfxcYUPlL |
|
Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here |
||
Paper 6.1: Putting Life into a Stone Age Dwelling Construction: A Joint Experimental Venture of Volunteers and Academics by Annelou van Gijn (NL) |
||
Paper 6.2: The Contribution of different Generations of Experiments on understanding the Function of past Human Technologies and the Character of early Hominin Decision-making Processes by Joao Marreiros (DE,PT), Ivan Calandra (DE), Geoff Carver (DE), Walter Gneinsinger (DE), Eduardo Paixao (PT), Jérôme Robitaille (DE), Lisa Schunk (DE,PL) |
||
Paper 6.3: Manual Vs. Mechanised Experiments – Evaluating the Effect of Human Variability on Tool Performance and Use-Wear Formation by Lisa Schunk (PL,DE), Ivan Calandra (DE), Walter Gneisinger (DE), João Marreiros (DE,PT) |
||
Paper 6.4: Perspectives on the Importance of prior Understanding for an Experimental Archaeological Project by Vibeke Bischoff (DK) |
||
Poster 6.5: Technotypes Definition and Cultural Transmission by Concepción Torres Navas (ES) |
||
Poster 6.6: NFDI4Objects – TRAIL3.3: A Workflow Tool for archaeological Experiments and Analytics by Ivan Calandra (DE), Geoff Carver (DE), João Marreiros (DE), Erica Hanning (DE), Roeland Paardekooper (DK), Christoph Berthold (DE), Susanne Greiff (DE) |
||
Poster 6.7: PCI Registered Reports for Experimental Archaeology: how to improve Experimental Design before it is too late by Ivan Calandra (DE) |
||
10:25 | Questions & Answers Session 6 | |
11:00 | Coffee Break | |
11:15 | Session 7A Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1OrOqbXLKRXGMU2UIsiKO3u |
Session 7B Location: Room 008 Moderator: Roeland Paardekooper Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1NSpdrDyBgsnoYteMOdAFh7 |
Sponsor: Faculty of History NCU in Toruń Promotional video of Faculty of History NCU |
Sponsor: Rector Magnificus of the NCU in Toruń The Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń (NCU) |
|
Sponsor: Faculty of History NCU in Toruń Cradle of the Piast. Lednica Lake underwater archaeological project |
Sponsor: Faculty of History NCU in Toruń Research of the NCU Center of Underwater Archeology: Puck 2017-2020 |
|
Paper 7.A.1: The Sound of Success in the Early Palaeolithic; Better Knapping is Brighter, Clearer and More Attention Grabbing by Kiefer Duffy, Mark White, Sally Street (UK) |
Paper 7.B.1: Vounous Symposium: Present and Future Plans by E. Giovanna Fregni (IT) |
|
Paper 7.A.2: Size Matters? Evaluating Correlation between Wide to Thickness Ratio and Breakage Patterns during Cinegetic Activities of Upper Solutrean Hunter-Gatherers. The Winged and Stemmed Points Case by Martín Julio García Natale, Samuel Castillo Jiménez (ES) |
Paper 7.B.2: Baltic Experimental Archaeology and Ancient Technology Summer School Between Science, Education, And Tourism: Conclusions after first 10 Years by Artūrs Tomsons (LV) |
|
Paper 7.A.3: Is it Worth Curating? Production, Use and Maintenance of the Neolithic Metabasite-Made Macrolithic Tools by Bernadeta Kufel-Diakowska (PL), Marcin Chłoń (PL), Michał Borowski (PL), Radomir Tichý (CZ), Karel Kučírek (CZ), Martin Drahorád (CZ), Aleš Panáček (CZ) |
Paper 7.B.3: Impact of High Temperatures on Macroscopic Features of Prehistoric Pottery by Jan Ledwoń (PL) |
|
Paper 7.A.4: Investigating Flint Awl Snapping in the British Mesolithic Using Integrated Methods by Andy Needham (UK), Jessica Bates (UK), Aimée Little (UK), Nicky Milner (UK), Diederik Pomstra (NL) |
Paper 7.B.4: Nurture Visitor Experience Through Experimentation: in Search of Antique Clothing by Gaëlle Desgouttes, Laure Vergonzanne, Céline Nicolas (FR) |
|
Paper 7.A.5: From Mould to Earth: Experimental and Traceological Study of Lusatian Socketed Axes by Kamil Nowak, Albin Sokół, Dawid Sych (PL) |
Paper 7.B.5: Hands-On History: Teaching Experimental Archaeology in a School Setting by Nathalie Roy (US) |
|
Poster 7.A.6: Youth Science. NCU Students’ Achievements by Zuzanna Majbrodzka, Kacper Baranowski, Anna Rauchfleisz, Maria Skudlarska, Maciej Urban, Klaudia Wernerowicz (PL) |
||
12:35 | Questions & Answers Session 7.A | Questions & Answers Session 7.B |
13:15 | Lunch | |
14:30 | Session 8A Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1Oelj0Sq0SzHCZr2r9I9s7L |
Session 8B Location: Room 008 Moderator: Giovanna Fregni Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1PhqLDzsCWzbFn5TW5kGVEF |
Introduction: EXARC and its Opportunities | Introduction: EXARC and its Opportunities | |
Paper 8.A.1: Experimental Study of Grinding Installation by Ana Tetruashvili, Davit Dolaberidze, Tina Davadze (GE) |
Paper 8.B.1: A Multitude of Microorganisms: Mediating Historical Drink Recreation by Laura Angotti (US) |
|
Paper 8.A.2: Grinding or Polishing? Replicating grinding and polishing Traces found on Neolithic flint Axes by Lasse van den Dikkenberg (NL) |
Paper 8.B.2: Experiments to Elucidate Cooking Methods Using Reconstructed Pottery by Tetsuya Shiroishi, Hashiguchi Yutaka (JP) |
|
Paper 8.A.3: Physics of Bipolar Reduction: Quantitative Approach to the bipolar Mechanic through Video Motion Analysis by Görkem Cenk Yeşilova, Adrián Arroyo, Andreu Ollé, Josep Maria Vergès (ES) |
Paper 8.B.3: Comparative Cheesemaking: Roman and Neolithic Cheese and the Ceramic Vessels Used to Produce them by Scott D Stull (US) |
|
Paper 8.A.4: “Slugs” of the Itaparica Tradition, an experimental Approach of the GO-JA-01 Collection by José Lucas Otero Couto, Sibele Aparecida Viana, Edilson Teixeira (BR) |
Paper 8.B.4: Stypsis, Wine and Resin – Technology of Scented Oil Production from Bronze Age Aegean and Beyond by Katarzyna Gromek (US) |
|
Paper 8.A.5: Set In Stone – Ornamentation of Stone Battle-Axes from the Experimental Perspective by Wojciech Bronowicki, Tomasz Płonka, Marcin Chłoń (PL) |
Paper 8.B.5: Lithics From the Neolithic Shell-Bead Workshops from The Near East - an Experimental Approach by Katarzyna Pyżewicz, Marcin Białowarczuk, Witold Grużdź, Michał Przeździecki (PL) |
|
Poster 8.A.6: Unconventional Use of Axes: Creating a Reference Collection of Polished Stone Tools Used for Grinding Ochre by Anđa Petrović (UK), Diederik Pomstra (UK,NL) Aimée Little (UK) |
Poster 8.B.6: First View on Functions of Bronze Age Pottery Vessels from Southwest Poland by Aleksandra Gawron-Szymczyk (PL) |
|
Poster 8.A.7: The Importance of Flintknapping Demonstrations and Workshops in Order to Further Develop Experimental Archaeology in Brazil by Maria Eduarda Vilela e Donegá (BR), Rafael Carvalho (BR), Leticia Correa (BR), João Carlos Moreno (BR), Mercedes Okumura (BR), Astolfo Araujo (BR), Bruce Bradley (US) |
||
Poster 8.A.8: The Use of Charcoal in the Production of Rock Art from Patagonia (Southern South America). An Experimental Perspective by Ariel David Frank (AR) |
||
16:00 | Coffee Break | |
16:15 | Session 9A Location: Room 009 Moderator: Jess Shaw Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1NIy42-_BpUKfDiTKXTj_Ur |
Session 9B Location: Room 008 Moderator: Giovanna Fregni Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1OrxW3NW7-alQ6FCMa7XU9b |
Sponsor: University of Wrocław | Sponsor: Dark Ages Re-Creation Company | |
Paper 9.A.1: The Origin and Evolution of cultural Transmission in Hominins as observed in Experimental and Experiential Archaeology by Maria Eduarda Vilela e Donegá, João Carlos Moreno (BR) |
Paper 9.B.1: “Look at the Bones!” - Adding Bone in a Bloomery Iron Smelt. A Case Study of a practical experimental Test by Darrell Markewitz (CA) |
|
Paper 9.A.2: Working Vegetal Materials with Obsidian, Basalt and other Volcanic Rocks. Exploring Similarities and Differences through Use-Wear Analysis by Idaira Brito-Abrante, Amelia Rodríguez-Rodríguez (ES) |
Paper 9.B.2: Experimental Archaeology and Assumptions about the Products from Prehistoric Ancient Iron Smelting Sites of Northern Thailand by Yoddanai Sukkasam (TH) |
|
Paper 9.A.3: Oxygen and Temperature may be the Driving Factors in Deciding the Types of Necrobiome in a Wrapped Microenvironment by Branka Franicevic (UK) |
Paper 9.B.3: Breaking Through the Copper Curtain: Archaeological Experiment of Copper Ore Beneficiation and Smelting in Chalcolithic Technology by Inbar Meyerson, Omri Yagel, Erez Ben-Yosef (IL) |
|
Poster 9.A.4: Mining or Ore-Processing Bone Tools? A Case Study from Eastern Ukraine by Olga Zagorodnia (UK) |
Paper 9.B.4: Does Corrosion Matter? Experimental Study of the Influence of Patination on Use-Wear Traces on the Copper Alloy Metalwork by Jakub Michalik, Kamil Nowak (PL) |
|
Poster 9.A.5: Can we identify Handedness on the Gönnersdorf Plaquettes? An experimental Approach on the Lateralisation of Upper Palaeolithic Engravers by Jérôme Robitaille (DE), Lisa-Elen Meyering (UK) |
||
17:15 | Questions & Answers Session 8.A and 9.A | Questions & Answers Session 8.B and 9.B |
18:00 | Closing Notes Only in person in Poland. Location: Room 009 |
20:00 | Session 10 ONLINE ONLY Moderator: Phoebe Baker Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLqWUT1pOFU1MZX_0r7BDZNMNB9-tCSnBM |
Sponsor: Marshal of the Kujawsko-Pomorskie Region Kujawsko-pomorskie - I like to be here |
|
Introduction: EXARC and its Opportunities | |
Paper 10.1: Circle of Life: Trevisker Ware by Laura-Marie Miucci (IE) |
|
Paper 10.2: The Investigation of Recent Reconstruction of Black and Red Figure Lekythoi for Restoration Purposes Through X-Ray and X-Ray Fluorescence Spectroscopy. Ethical Restoration Practice or Not? by A.P. Panagopoulou (GR,NL), A. Mandaliou (GR), G. Rousouneli (GR), M. Roggenbucke (GR) |
|
Paper 10.3: Creating Red: Reproducing Opaque Red Glass from Iron Age Western and Central Europe by Rachel Wood (US) |
|
Paper 10.4: A Comparison of two Merovingian Pottery Kilns Found in Belgium. Results of the Experiment and Tool for Experimental Research by Line van Wersch, Marie Demelenne, Sylvie De Longueville, Véronique Danese (BE) |
|
Paper 10.5: Belting Up; Building Technical Literacies in the History of Technology Through Experimental Archaeology by Michael Roberts (CA) |
|
Paper 10.6: Experimenter's Body Analysis: a Transdisciplinary Approach by Thaisa Martins (BR) |
|
21:40 | Questions & Answers Session 10 and Closing Notes |
Day 3 - Wednesday, May 3, 2023
What: | Where: | |
Excursion | Muzeum Archeologiczne w Biskupinie incl bus, entry, coffee and lunch
We should be back in Toruń around 18:30h - 19:00h. |
Abstracts
Updated, April 15, 2023
Experimental Archaeology In Poland – History, Science and Education (keynote)
Grzegorz Osipowicz1, Justyna Orłowska1, Justyna Kuriga1
1 Institute of Archaeology, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland
The presentation will consist of four parts. The first one will discuss the history of research using experimental archaeology in Poland. The most important works, people and centres conducting studies in this field in the 20th century will be presented. The second part of the presentation will be devoted to experimental archaeology, understood as a method (tool) of scientific research. The most important and interesting scientific achievements made in Poland using an archaeological experiment will be discussed here. In the third part, we will focus on presenting the main centres conducting research in the field of experimental archaeology in our country. Both centres conducting purely scientific activities and those concentrating to a large extent on the popularization of science (e.g. archaeological parks) will be included here. We will present their reconstructions and the educational activities they conduct. The last part of the presentation will be devoted to activities in the field of historical reconstruction that are carried out in Poland. We will present here the most important events of this type that take place in our country.
A Multitude of Microorganisms: Mediating Historical Drink Recreation (paper)
Laura Angotti1
1 Independent Scholar, USA
Understanding the nature and flavors of historical fermented drinks through experimental recreation requires both an understanding of relevant microorganisms and a considered approach to selection of an appropriate modern fermentation culture. Beyond the basic production of energy by metabolizing sugar to alcohol and CO2, different microorganisms produce widely divergent by-products and co-products, fundamentally influencing the character of the produced drink. This paper approaches culture selection through three methodologies: review of recent scientific analyses establishing historical context, evaluation of drink character from recreation of versions of a core recipe from primary sources using modeled cultures, and development of a practical and philosophical framework to selecting modern cultures for experimentation.
A review of selected studies of yeast genomes and historical fermentation residues establishes the variability of these cultures and the distance between modern cultures and historical predecessors, providing context for selection of modern analogs.
For experimentation, an exemplar mead recipe was used that emerges into a widely distributed Western European medical formularies with the translation of Arabic writings in the 11th and 12th centuries, persisting well after the recipe loses its medical connotations starting in the 16th century. Fermentation cultures modeled from recipe specifics include yeast/leaven, ale/beer barm, wine lees, and sour leaven. As expected, results varied widely.
This review and the experimental results confirm an approach that acknowledges the lack of direct correlation between historical and modern cultures while leveraging the analogous variability of modern commercial and wild microorganisms into experimental design. It is expected that this framework can be used to continue integrating multidisciplinary developments while incorporating more detailed considerations of microorganisms into the experiments exploring the nature of historical fermented drinks.
What Did Neanderthals Wear on Their Feet? An Experimental Archaeological Investigation of Neanderthal Footwear (paper)
Phoebe Baker1, Andy Needham1
1 University of York, UK
Despite increasing interest in aspects of Neanderthal clothing and the tools that may have been used to make them, little dedicated work has been devoted to their footwear. The lack of direct examples of Middle Palaeolithic clothing - and indirect traces of complex clothing, such as needles - has shaped debate, with a focus on the fundamentals, such as whether clothing was required for survival, linked to changes in environment and ecology. In the case of footwear, it was likely essential to survival in some Middle Palaeolithic contexts, but strictly unnecessary in others. However, despite this recognition that clothing may have been essential to survival in some times and places, little work has been done to explore the potential of the materials that were available, how this could be made into footwear with the tools available to Neanderthals, and its efficacy.
A series of experiments were designed to test potential Neanderthal footwear configurations and their efficacy. Five different configurations of footwear were tested which ranged in their ‘complexity’, including examples proposed in the literature and novel configurations utilising materials and methods thought to have been available during the Middle Palaeolithic. Each configuration of footwear was worn and assessed qualitatively via direct observation and quantitatively via a thermal camera. The former approach allowed for consideration of wearability and durability, while the latter provided data on insulative properties. The results indicate that ‘simplicity’ in shoe design can be beneficial to their insulation and wearability, depending on the specific configuration. The results encourage a revisiting of discussions surrounding ‘simple’ versus ‘complex’ clothing in Neanderthals.
Iron Age Combustion Structures in the Western Mediterranean: an Approach from the Experimental Archaeology (paper)
Maria-Carme Belarte1,2, María Pastor Quiles2, Marta Portillo3, Carme Saorin4, Marta Mateu Sagués2, Alessandra Pecci4, Sílvia Vila5, Josep Pou6, Georgina Castells6, Jordi Morer7, Joaquín Fernández8
1 ICREA, Spain; 2 ICAC, Spain; 3 IMF CSIC, Spain; 4 UB, Spain; 5 UdL, Spain; 6 Calafell Town Council, Calafell, Spain; 7 Món Iber ROCS, Spain; 8 UAB, Spain
We present the experimental works on Iron Age combustion structures carried out within the framework of the project Transdisciplinary and experimental study of combustion structures in the western Mediterranean during Protohistory (TRANSCOMB project). These have been conducted between 2021 and 2022 at the "Iberian Citadel of Calafell" (Tarragona, Spain) archaeological site. The experiment has been performed on present-day replicas of archaeological hearths and ovens based on archaeological documentation coming from Iron Age sites of the Iberian culture (Mediterranean coastal area of the Iberian Peninsula). Experimental works included the use of various fuel-types (wood, grasses and animal dung), according to the available archaeobotanical records (anthracological and microfossil analyses). Variables such as increased heating and time are measured, in order to determine whether variations occur, depending on the fuels used, the type of structure or its location. Samples of the sediment composing these structures as well as fuel remains after each combustion have been systematically collected for interdisciplinary analyses and comparison with archaeological structures.
Smash and Burn: Apple Seed Damage Characteristics for the Identification of Actions and Processes Performed on Apples (paper)
Jessi Berndt1
1 Institute for Archaeological Sciences, University of Tübingen, Germany
This paper will discuss two related sets of experiments designed for establishing morphological damage datasets of characteristics found on apple seeds as the result of various processes performed on the fruits. By applying experimental archaeology to archaeobotany, it is the purpose of this research to assist in the interpretation of archaeobotanical apple finds and thus to aid in the understanding of the role of apples, as an economic and ornamental crop, and in its processing and consumption as food and drink. The results of the experiments will be applied to interpret charred apple finds of the Middle Neolithic site of Oberderdingen, in Germany.
The current presentation will focus on the experimental setting and its design. The first set of experiments will establish the pre-depositional primary damage characteristics. Subsequently the morphological patterns which occur as a result of cider production, as well as kitchen waist, human mastication, and the control will be simulated. This set of experiments include a partial digestions simulation.
Applying this research to the apple finds of the Oberderdingen site required expanding the research to include charring morphologies. Therefore, an additional set of experiments will account for the influence of charring on the damage characteristics of the processed apples and especially their seeds. The charring experiments, although designed with the specific conditions of the artifacts from Oberderdingen in mind, will be of value for the interpretation of apple seed finds of other sites from other periods.
Perspectives on the Importance of prior Understanding for an Experimental Archaeological Project (paper)
Vibeke Bischoff1
1The Viking Ship Museum in Roskilde, Denmark
In 2012, a full-scale reconstruction of the Oseberg Ship from 820, Saga Oseberg, was launched as part of an experimental archaeological project, designed to investigate the ship’s sailing capabilities. The initial test-sailing was conducted in line with the principles for handling traditional West Norwegian square-sailed boats from the 19th and 20th centuries. The ship performed badly, and the reconstruction was judged to be incorrect. Subsequent test-sailing in 2015 undertaken with a more open and investigative methodology was conducted, which gave rise to more positive results.
In this paper, I will present my thoughts on the importance of prior understanding based on my experiences with the Oseberg Ship, but I believe that there are parallels to other types of projects too, whether they are houses built on land or ships at sea. Our prior understanding and experience have an impact on the questions we ask of both the archaeological material and the reconstruction – and on the results we achieve.
Focus on the importance of prior understanding for both reconstruction and their subsequent testing, must be addressed. Our bodily approaches as humans have such a significant impact on all processes that it is a vital, we have an awareness of it. Prior understanding and experience can be used to ask relevant questions and conduct investigations, not to find answers, as reconstructions are an interpretation of an artefact, and the results will therefore render probabilities rather than present concrete truths.
We who work with experimental archaeology, must be conscious, reflective and descriptive in terms of our prior understanding in relation to the projects we work with, because we are modern people attempting to interpret the actions of people from another time.
Working Vegetal Materials with Obsidian, Basalt and other Volcanic Rocks. Exploring Similarities and Differences through Use-Wear Analysis (paper)
Idaira Brito-Abrante1, Amelia Rodríguez-Rodríguez1
1 Grupo de Investigación TARHA, Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain
Volcanic rocks and glasses are raw materials that have been widely used upon the time in many chronological and cultural contexts. Despite their ubiquity and importance, they have received uneven attention. Obsidian has benefited from many technological and functional studies, while the other rocks much less, especially in use-wear analysis. Perhaps some reasons are their variability and that many of them bear rough surfaces, making it difficult to analyse and interpret tools.
This paper presents the preliminary results of an experimental programme to approach use-wear analysis of these volcanic materials in an integrated way. We have used them to work different contact materials of vegetable nature: fresh and dry wood, cereals, reeds and palm. This strategy has offered information, on one hand, about their effectiveness while carrying out the same activities. On the other hand, and most important, letting to compare the behaviour of the use-wear: types of observable variables, associations, frequency, time of appearance, development, and so on, providing wider criteria to analyse working process. Our reference context of study are the lithic industries recorded in the Canary Island during the pre-Hispanic period. The Archipelago was colonized by Amazigh/Berber populations around the beginning of the Era. Native people remained isolated until the European arrival in the late Middle Ages. Their way of life, based in agriculture and husbandry, was developed entirely with lithic tools because there are no metal ores. In addition, the Archipelago environmental conditions are ideal for the preservation of organic remains in the archaeological record, as dried timber, wood artefacts and tools, basketry, and textiles.
Set In Stone – Ornamentation of Stone Battle-Axes from the Experimental Perspective (paper)
Wojciech Bronowicki1 , Tomasz Płonka1, Marcin Chłoń1
1 University of Wrocław, Poland
Stone processing is a heavy work even for the contemporary artists. However, the Neolithic communities mastered this difficult craft, the products of which have survived for centuries. Through careful examination, using various techniques we are able to collect information about the process of production of stone tools and reconstruct various phases in the chain of operations. In this paper we focus on the rarest and unique activity of this sequence - decoration.
We present the results of experimental and use-wear studies on the process of ornamentation of stone tools. The case studies are two engraved battle-axes of the Corded Ware culture from SW Poland. One of them was found in Budziszów Wielki 2/3 and was made of diabase; second one come from Kurzątkowice 7 and was made of serpentinite. Both of them are decorated with an arrangement of engraved lines that go around the surface of the artifacts. In order to replicate the process various experiments were prepared to provide reference collection for interpretations of techniques and tools used in ornamentation.
This study is part of a project supported by the National Science Centre, Poland (2020/38/E/HS3/00285).
PCI Registered Reports for Experimental Archaeology: how to improve Experimental Design before it is too late (poster)
Ivan Calandra1
1 TraCEr, Laboratory for Traceology and Controlled Experiments, MONREPOS, RGZM, Neuwied, Germany
Archaeological experiments require time and money, so ensuring that the experimental design is sound and appropriate to test the hypotheses before conducting the experiments would avoid wasting investments. Registered reports (RRs) can help with this aspect because the study design is peer-reviewed and pre-accepted before the research is undertaken. RRs are evaluated solely on the questions they ask and on the quality of the proposed methods, not on the results.
Peer review for RRs takes place over two stages. At Stage 1, authors submit their research question(s), theory and hypotheses, and detailed methods (including experimental design) and analysis plans. Proposals that are favorably peer-reviewed receive in-principle acceptance, which commits to accepting the final article regardless of the results. The authors then perform the research and submit a Stage 2 manuscript that includes the approved protocol plus results and discussion. The reviewers from Stage 1 assess this completed Stage 2 manuscript, focusing only on compliance with protocol and whether the conclusions are justified by the evidence.
The Peer Community In Registered Reports (PCI-RR) is a community dedicated to receiving, reviewing, and recommending registered reports. PCI-RR offers several advantages to authors:
- Authors get feedback (review) when it is most useful, i.e. before conducting the experiment, to improve and optimize the experimental design before it is too late.
- Papers are accepted before starting the experiments, even if the results turn out to be not as "great" as expected.
- One Stage 1 manuscript can lead to multiple Stage 2 outputs, which is particularly relevant for large experimental programs.
- Scheduled review to accelerate the review process.
- Open data and transparent review.
- Free for all (diamond open access).
NFDI4Objects – TRAIL3.3: A workflow tool for archaeological experiments and analytics (poster)
Ivan Calandra1, Geoff Carver1, João Marreiros1, Erica Hanning2, Roeland Paardekooper3, Christoph Berthold4, Susanne Greiff5
1 TraCEr, Laboratory for Traceology and Controlled Experiments, MONREPOS, RGZM, Neuwied, Germany
2 Laboratory for Experimental Archaeology, RGZM, Germany
3 EXARC, the Netherlands
4 Competence Center Archaeometry Baden-Württemberg, University of Tübingen, Germany
5 Institute for Pre- and Protohistory and Medieval Archaeology, University of Tübingen, Germany
An experiment is part of a formal scientific process, testing a hypothesis. Every archaeological interpretation of an object’s manufacture or use is a hypothesis to be tested. Archaeologists often lack the infrastructure, theoretical basis, resources and/or tools to do this testing or disseminate their protocols and results. Additionally, few experimental reports are detailed enough for the procedures to be repeatable and/or results to be reproducible. Consequently, experimental archaeology urgently needs to develop ways of reporting, documenting and sharing the designs and results of experiments.
The aim of this pilot project is to produce a prototype of a flexible, visual workflow tool for recording experiment design and the protocol of a sample preparation procedure or analysis. This tool should help experimenters plan better and avoid misrunning experiments, reducing the waste of time and resources. It should also address the issues of repeatability/reproducibility by considering three aspects of data acquisition:
Why were the data generated (= Research questions/hypotheses/motivation)?
How were the data generated (samples, method, equipment, and associated accuracy/precision, etc.)?
Why they were generated in that way: methods are often employed without questioning their appropriateness for the given samples and/or hypotheses. This illustrates a reflexive process.
The tool developed within this project should highlight the role of experimentation within the archaeological process and strengthen the epistemological basis of archaeological interpretation as a whole.
Experimental Cremations in Different burning Environments: Open versus semi-close Pyre in Crete, Greece (paper)
Yannis Chatzikonstantinou1, Evangelia Kiriatzi2, Sevasti Triantaphyllou1
1 Department of History and Archaeology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece
2 Fitch Laboratory, The British School at Athens, Greece
Experimental pyrotechnology of burning conditions affecting bone tissue provides a deep understanding of fire technology and the changes in bone structure related to fire. Although the destructive forces of fire alter the morphological features of bones, they also offer valuable information on the intensity of the fire, the duration of the burning events, the amount of fuel that was necessary for the manipulation of the fire, the original atmosphere, and the place of burning. TEFRA Project, examining the custom of cremation in Aegean Prehistory, incorporates extensive experimental work through the detailed investigation of the extrinsic factors affecting the combustion process. Two burning episodes were set in different burning environments (open versus semi-close pyre) in which pig carcasses, semi-fleshed, and defleshed pig bones were burnt until complete calcination. This paper presents the preliminary results of the recent experiments conducted in Crete, Greece, including observations concerning pyrotechnology, burning fuel, achieved temperatures, duration of the combustion process, and assessment of the burning level and thermal alterations of the bones.
The Bronze Age Chariot of the Sintashta-Petrovka Period (paper)
Igor Chechushkov1, Ivan Semyan2
1 University of Colorado, USA
2 Caucasus Institute, Yerevan, Armenia
Our report is dedicated to study the Bronze Age chariot of the Sintashta-Petrovka period (the 2nd mil. BCE) by means of the scientific experiment. Based on data of 28 chariot graves and a series of cheekpieces, we conducted a study of the bridle with cheekpieces as a control system of harnessed horses. It was found that soft bits with cheekpieces are more effective than a simple halter, and less effective than modern metal bits.
Based on ancient petroglyphs, we made a harness system using leather and felt, and found that it was suitable for chariot horses. The reconstructed chariot demonstrated reliability, stability, and maneuverability. The time spent on making a chariot using authentic technologies can be estimated within 2-4 months and considering the harvesting and drying of wood - at least 1 year. The creation of a chariot complex in the conditions of a communal organization of labor imposed a constant burden on all the procurement of the necessary resources.
The training of the charioteer, according to the experiment, required at least 3-6 hours to develop from scratch the elementary skills of driving horses and balancing in the back of a moving cart and tens of hours to develop professional skills. The training of horses also took tens of hours to develop the skill of working together and obeying the commands of the driver and required the participation of at least two specialists.
The minimum size of a professional team that creates and maintains a chariot complex can be estimated at 4-6 people without considering the procurement of raw materials, and the time spent on preparing a chariot is 1-1.5 years, which was a great investment for the community.
The late Viking Age warship, Skuldelev 5: exploring old interpretations with a new reconstruction (paper)
Martin R. Dael1 & Tríona Sørensen1
1 The Viking Ship Museum in Roskilde, Denmark
In 1962, five late Viking Age ships were excavated from Roskilde Fjord, in Denmark. The form and function of the Skuldelev Ships, as they came to be known, embodies the diversity and range of seafaring and shipbuilding in the late Viking Age: vessels for fishing, coastal and ocean-going trade, and two examples of the most iconic Viking Age craft of all – the long, narrow and well-rowed warships.
The Viking Ship Museum’s boatyard completed the first round of full-scale, experimental archaeological reconstruction of all five Skuldelev Ships in 2004. Since then, work has focused on the ‘second generation’ of Skuldelev reconstructions and in July 2022, a project focused on a new full-scale reconstruction of the 17,6 m long warship, Skuldelev 5, began.
The construction of Skuldelev 5 is unique when compared with other late Viking Age ship-finds. From the outset, the ship was built using reused material taken from at least two other vessels and the hull is also composed of several different species of wood. These details have led to a degree of academic discussion regarding the ship’s construction and use.
This paper will present an introduction to the framework for the new Skuldelev 5 reconstruction project, seen from both a boatbuilder’s and an archaeologist’s perspective. The complexities – and peculiarities – of the original ship’s hull, and previous interpretations of the ship-find, will be explored, providing the foundation for a new dialogue concerning the construction and use of the original ship-find, and the research programme in development for the forthcoming full-scale reconstruction.
Nurture Visitor Experience Through Experimentation: in Search of Antique Clothing (paper)
Gaëlle Desgouttes1, Laure Vergonzanne1, Céline Nicolas1
1 Musée et sites gallo-romains de Saint-Romain-en-Gal, Département du Rhône, France
Since the beginning of the 1980s, the gallo-roman sites and museum of Saint-Romain-en-Gal in the Rhône (France) develops experimental archaeology.
In 2014, the museum initiate a research regarding ancient textiles and clothing. The statues and paintings are rich of many detailed features, some of them not even mentioned in the textual sources from the time, and we tried to find a way to pass this knowledge onto our visitors. Therefore we recreate pieces of clothing, hand sewn and hand-dyed. We use them to better understand what is implied in wearing: the way you feel, the movements it allows and the effects it can have on your posture.
The re-creations are documented, using archaeological studies related to textiles from the whole Mediterranean area, as well with iconographic sources.
Occasionally we also use some text evidences regarding the roman clothing.
One of the question that occurs was to find a way to obtain a curve in front of the legs using a rectangular shaped mantle, because it’s a feature that can be observed on many women statues from roman times. One of the purpose is the work on the tacit knowledge, to find a way to match what can be observed on the roman statues and a practical way to be dressed in roman times, while being as close as possible to the people, who they could be and what they could wear. But it’s also a reflexion on the process that leads from the fibre to the finally wear clothing and the body shape induced.
Experimental Tattooing and Analysis of Preserved Skin Markings on Human Mummies (paper)
Aaron Deter-Wolf1, Danny Riday2, Maya Sialuk Jacobsen3
1 Tennessee Division of Archaeology, USA
2 The Temple Tattoo, New Zealand
3 Inuit Tattoo Traditions, Greenland
Preserved tattoos are present on mummified human remains from archaeological sites across five continents, and date back at least 5,300 years before present. Recent scholarship has greatly expanded scientific and popular understanding of the temporal scope and cultural importance of ancient tattooing traditions. However, there remains only limited reliable knowledge as to what tools and techniques were used for creating tattoos in past societies. From 2021-2022 our international research team conducted an experimental study supported by an EXARC Research Award, in which we examined the physical signatures of tattoos created on human skin using different traditional tools and methods. This presentation describes our experiment and expands on that study, applying our findings to examinations of tattoos preserved on the skin of mummies from Europe, Siberia, and South America. Our analyses help illuminate the potential methods used to create these preserved tattoos and correct earlier assumptions regarding tattooing artifacts and methods.
Grinding or Polishing? Replicating grinding and polishing Traces found on Neolithic flint Axes (paper)
Lasse van den Dikkenberg1
1 Leiden University, the Netherlands
Sites from the Neolithic Vlaardingen Culture (3400-2500 BC) often yield large quantities of polished axe fragments, and occasionally even complete axes are found. When studying the flint from two Vlaardingen Culture sites, Den Haag Steynhof and Hekelingen III, it became apparent that the axe fragments on both sites yielded very different finishing traces. To better understand the observed differences an experimental program was set-up to replicate these grinding and polishing traces. The experiments created a suitable reference collection for the study of these traces. Using optical microscopy we could match the replicated traces to those observed on the Neolithic axe fragments. On one site it appeared that most axes were only ground while the other site mainly yielded polished axe fragments. The polished fragments were generally polished with leather and additives. Combining experimental archaeology with optical microscopy proved to be important as it allowed us to grasp differences left by different finishing procedures which macroscopically could not have been distinguished. The experiments allowed us to distinguish between grinding on a grinding stone, with and without the inclusion of sand. Furthermore, we could distinguish between flint which was polished on a soft type of stone and flint which was polished with leather and additives.
The experiments gave valuable insights into the finishing stages of these axes, but they also raised new questions. It was generally assumed that these axes were imported to these sites in a finished state. Do these differences in finishing traces indicate that the finishing takes place in these Vlaardingen Culture settlements, rather than on the production sites? Or did different communities import different types of axes?
The origin and evolution of cultural transmission in hominins as observed in experimental and experiential archaeology (paper)
Maria Eduarda Vilela e Donegá1 & João Carlos Moreno2
1 Laboratory for Human Evolutionary Studies, Institute of Biosciences, University of São Paulo, Brazil
2 Laboratory of Evolutionary and Experimental Archaeology and Prehistory, Institute of Humanities and Information, Federal University of Rio Grande, Brazil
Studies regarding the origin and development of cultural transmission have been the focus of evolutionary academics in the last decade. Many approaches have been carried out, presenting different results and different suggestions regarding the coevolution of lithic technology and cultural transmission. In this paper I aim to understand how complex should be the communication between an experienced knapper and an apprentice so he/she can learn how to reproduce the same tools many times without failing. The project main objective is to carry out an experiment that applies different levels of complexity of learning how to produce Early and Mid-Paleolithic (2,6 Ma – 100 ka) tools from Africa and Eurasia. The implications of this project are related to the study of cultural transmission between the early species of the Homo genus and presents different levels of complexity. The complexity levels to be experimented vary from low (observation and imitation) to high (use of oral and visual language), so that it becomes possible to observe the development of the apprentice on producing tools and to deduce what kind of cultural transmission type was required between by hominins. Preliminary results of this experiential study suggest that Oldowan and Early Acheulean main artifacts production can be learned by only imitation and observation, while Late Acheulean and Mousterian main artifacts production require complex teaching methods and some level of language.
The Importance of Flintknapping Demonstrations and Workshops in Order to Further Develop Experimental Archaeology in Brazil
(poster)
Maria Eduarda Vilela e Donegá1,3 Rafael Carvalho1, Leticia Correa2, João Carlos Moreno1, Mercedes Okumura3, Astolfo Araujo2, Bruce Bradley4
1 LAPEEX. Laboratory for Evolutionary and Experimental Archaeology and Prehistory, FURG, Brazil
2 LEVOC. Laboratory for Interdisciplinary Studies in Evolution, Culture, and Environment, USP, Brazil
3 LEEH. Laboratory for Human Evolutionary Studies, USP, Brazil
4 Dept. of Archaeology, University of Exeter, UK
The aim of this abstract is to raise awareness on the importance of Experimental Archaeology as well as flintknapping training and demonstrations in order to better understand Brazilian lithic assemblages. Since 2012, the three senior authors have been organizing hands on workshops and flintknapping demonstrations by Bruce Bradley to Brazilian researchers, students, and the general public. The six flintknapping demonstrations (four in São Paulo state, one in Rio de Janeiro and one in Minas Gerais state in 2011, 2012, 2016, 2018, 2020, and 2022) reached around 150 people and they have been important tools to educate researchers, students, as well as the general public about archaeology and stone tools in general. The four hands-on workshops (2016, 2018, 2021 and 2022, all in São Paulo state) involved 41 people in total. The workshops have had a pivotal role in shaping the discussions about lithic technology in Brazilian prehistoric assemblages, including important discussions about protocols of lithic analysis and, most importantly, the establishment of research lines in our laboratories that include experimental archaeology and the replication of lithic artifacts. Finally, the abovementioned activities related to Experimental Archaeology highlight the importance of international collaborations and knowledge sharing in terms of bringing new perspectives regarding lithic technology in Brazil, as well as educating the general public about Brazilian archaeology.
The Sound of Success in the Early Palaeolithic; Better Knapping is Brighter, Clearer and More Attention Grabbing (paper)
Kiefer Duffy1, Mark White1, Sally Street1
1 University of Durham, UK
The burgeoning field of lithoacoustics is beginning to recognise what stone toolmakers, daily users, experimental and hobbyist have long noted; It is noisy, and this noise is extremely useful and, when it goes well, enjoyable. The satisfying crack of a good removal is an extra reward for success. What are the properties of this sound and how does it vary across materials and strike types? Do better materials and successful strikes truly sound “better”. Do the responses of naïve, non-knapper listeners indicate a preference for this “sound of success”? To answer this question, stone tool-making sessions were recorded and analysed. We report significant differences in the sounds of flake producing strikes on higher quality raw materials compared to failed strikes or strikes on poorer quality materials in four categories of acoustic properties related to aesthetic perceptions in music. Furthermore, a questionnaire was delivered to 85 participants who were asked to listen to a sub-sample of recordings produced for the acoustic analysis. They answered questions exploring their aesthetic and attentional responses to the audio samples. This showed a clear pattern of higher quality, successful strikes being the most attention grabbing. However, aesthetic responses suggested respondents preferred the bassier, thuddier sounds produced by lower quality knapping materials. This implies that context and exposure is needed to appreciate the sound of success and that knappability isn’t entirely linked to aesthetic responses. These two components together provide insights into the acoustic properties of knapping and the ways in which hominins may have exploited the sonorous qualities of their stone to their benefit both technologically and socially.
How Warped the Loom. An Examination of Loom Traces on Woven Cloth (paper)
Jo Duke1
1 Independent Researcher, Ontario, Canada
Sometime between 1000 and 1800 CE, for much of Europe, there was a transition from weaving cloth on upright warp weighted looms to horizontal floor looms. This transition includes the addition of a reed beater as part of the mechanism of the loom and a switch from the warp being held under tension by loom weights to its supply and tensioning from a second beam.
One key question is: can the loom type be determined based on the textile remains, often small fragments, and, if so, what features are the most useful to look for?
To address this, replicates of selected textile finds from Europe and the North Atlantic have been woven using each of the two loom types and the qualities of the replicated fabrics have been examined for discriminating features. Focus was placed on the amount of draw in, the spacing of the threads, and the regulation of the warp tension. The use of a reed reduces draw in and adds uniformity to the spacing of warp threads. It also removes the need for a separate beater, and therefore changes how evenly the weft threads are packed in the cloth. The addition of a second beam may also reduce draw in and regulates the tension of the warp while weaving.
Oxygen and Temperature may be the Driving Factors in Deciding the Types of Necrobiome in a Wrapped Microenvironment (paper)
Branka Franicevic1
1 The School of Archaeological and Forensic Sciences, University of Bradford, UK
Human behavioural factors including mutilation and dismemberment may alter the growth and activity of necrobiome in the absence of necessary gastrointestinal organs. Depositional settings of individual body parts are in addition inadequately researched, leaving long-term implications for their location and recovery. The present study assessed the early decomposition of wrapped body parts using the domestic pig (Sus scrofa) as an animal analogue. The aim was to evaluate how the remains decompose under differing temperature levels, as tested by Viable Count, Gram stain, and cadaver biomass measurement. The analyses proved ambient temperature to significantly impact biomass loss of the remains. The results demonstrated differential decomposition between body parts and indicated facultative aerobic and anaerobic bacteria to be responsible for the decay. The controls suggested oxygen hindered the decay and demonstrated a specific decomposition pattern in reduced oxygen settings. This study advances taphonomic knowledge of individual body parts in the absence of flies and insects, important for replication in controlled conditions. The findings further serve as a base for field studies, of interest to a broader field of the medico-legal sphere, from pathologists to forensic anthropologists.
Keywords: Sus scrofa, necrobiome, body wrapping, taphonomy, biomass loss
The Use of Charcoal in the Production of Rock Art from Patagonia (Southern South America). An Experimental Perspective (poster)
Ariel David Frank1,2
1 Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET), Argentina
2 División Arqueología, Facultad de Ciencias Naturales y Museo, Universidad Nacional de La Plata, Argentina
The Central Plateau of Santa Cruz (Patagonia, Argentina) has abundant rock shelters where rock art has been painted. Figurative and non-figurative motifs are common, such as hand stencils, hunting scenes, guanacos and other animals, as well as lines, circles, and dots. Paintings were done with many different colors, such as red, white, black, yellow and orange. Chemical analyses show the use of inorganic pigments in the preparation of the paint: hematite, gypsum, goethite and manganese oxide, among others, were detected. Charcoal was identified in some of the sampled paintings. Although charcoal was used to produce black paints, it was also recorded in paintings made with other colors, especially red. Even though no specific studies have been developed about this issue, it has been proposed that the incorporation of charcoal particles to these paints was a way of achieving the desired color. However, alternative explanations can be suggested including the unintentional incorporation of charcoal particles to pigments during heat treatment, or the use of charcoal to modify the consistency of the paint. In this presentation I describe my experimental protocol to tackle this issue and present the first results of this investigation.
Vounous Symposium: Present and Future Plans (paper)
E. Giovanna Fregni1
1 Independent Researcher, Modena, Italy
The Vounous Symposium started in 2014 as an ambitious project led by a small group of ceramic artists who wanted to recreate the Archaic Age sculptures and art of Ayia Irini in Northern Cyprus. The Temple Area there was excavated by teams from Sweden, and most of the artifacts that were recovered were sent to that country. Their loss to Cyprus created a cultural vacuum that has been felt to this day. Using clay and materials from the same sources as the people of the Archaic Age of the region, they made replicas of the effigy statues and set up a permanent exhibit in the town hall near the ancient Temple.
After the completion of the project in Ayia Irini, Rauf Ersenal and his team saw the need for an ongoing project combining art, archaeology, and experimental archaeology to explore the local craft technology of the Bronze Age. This vision has evolved into the annual Vounous Symposium, where artists, researchers, and archaeologists have come together since 2017 to explore craft work and to conduct experiments incorporating ancient techniques using materials from the same sources that were in use in the Bronze Age.
Past symposia have included lectures by renowned researchers on ancient ceramic firing technology and the chemistry of terra sigilata. Experiments have also been made in recreating objects in oxidised ceramic firing, faience, and in smelting local copper ore. The ultimate goal of the symposium is to create a permanent open-air museum where research, lectures, and seminars can be held throughout the year.
Size Matters? Evaluating Correlation between Wide to Thickness Ratio and Breakage Patterns during Cinegetic Activities of Upper Solutrean Hunter-Gatherers. The Winged and Stemmed Points Case (paper)
Martín Julio García Natale1, Samuel Castillo Jiménez2
1 Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid, Spain
2 Departamento de Historia y Filosofía, Universidad de Alcalá de Henares, Alcalá de Henares, Spain
Winged and stemmed foliate points were one the main hunting weapons during the upper Solutrean technocomplex of Southwest Europe (∼21 – 18 ka cal BP). In this contribution we aim to understand breakage patterns during hunting activities related to tipometric values. We focus on the archaeological record of the upper Solutrean layers of the Parpalló Cave (Valencia) and Ambrosio Cave (Almería), where a large winged and stemmed foliate point collection has been recorded during the excavation process. Both of these sites have been chosen because this type of weapon was crafted with different tipometric values, being the Parpalló ones wider and thinner than the Ambrosio ones. Based on previous experiments, our hypothesis is based on the statement that wide to thickness ratio may be related with the type of fracture produced by impact during hunting activities.
We aim to test this hypothesis by means of an experimental protocol. To achieve this goal, we designed an experiment involving four steps:
- technological analysis of the upper Solutrean winged and stemmed foliate points by means of revisiting all the papers focused on this topic.
- experimental replication of both subgroups of points.
- recreation of hunting activities using the experimental points.
- comparison of breakage patterns between both groups.
Our results will contribute to the understanding of techno-economic behaviors of upper Solutrean hunter-gatherers.
First View on Functions of Bronze Age Pottery Vessels from Southwest Poland (poster)
Aleksandra Gawron-Szymczyk1
1 University of Wrocław, Poland
Ceramic vessels make large collections and the studies, according to a long-lasting Central European archaeological perspective, are focused mostly on their shapes (typology), chronology and provenance analyses. From the beginning of the Bronze Age, we can observe an unprecedented formal richness of clay vessels.
This poster presents first results of microscopic observations of use-alteration traces found on pottery vessels from the large settlement Wrocław-Widawa (late Bronze Age, ca. 900-750 BC)) and the urnfield at Miłosławice (late Bronze to early Iron Age, ca. 1100-550 BC). To explain origins of the observed microtraces (abrasion, scratches, chemical attritions) it was necessary to conduct a series of experiments. The results allow us to answer the question of whether vessels for storing, processing and serving food be identified, and how their morphology reflects the presumed function(s). Moreover, analysis of collections from both settlement and cemetery allows to compare the use patterns for every day and funeral purposes.
Phytoliths Reference Collection from the Experimental Perspective (paper)
Aleksandra Gawron-Szymczyk1
1 University of Wrocław, Poland
Phytoliths, defined as plant opal silica bodies, are the most resistant botanical remains in archaeological contexts. They may be collected directly from soil deposits and archaeological artefacts, such as grinding tools. Phytoliths identification requires reference samples. They are taken from modern plants and prepared with the use of two different methods: dry ashing technique or treatment with chemical agents. However, available reference collections of phytoliths include narrow range of plant samples from Central Europe. Also, relatively little Neolithic plant macroremains are preserved from this area.
My study is a part of the research project focused on understanding the Neolithic agriculture, crop processing and diet and includes the analysis of microremains from grinding tools of the Linear Pottery culture (LBK) in SW Poland (ca. 5400-4900/4800BC). Firstly, I propose an alternative, experimental method of collecting reference samples of phytoliths directly from plants added as admixture to clay and preserved as the archaeobotanical macroscopic remains inside daub lumps. Before the process of sonication and chemical extraction the plant species of macroremains were macroscopically defined. Second part of my experimental project is aimed in understanding the cognitive value of phytolith studies collected from the Neolithic grinding tools excavated decades ago and to check the contamination possibility. For this reason, I check the possible presence of phytoliths on the polishing slabs and adzes excavated from the same Neolithic contexts.
This study is part of a project supported by the National Science Centre, Poland (2020/38/E/HS3/00285).
Putting Life into a Stone Age Dwelling Construction: A Joint Experimental Venture of Volunteers and Academics (paper)
Annelou van Gijn1
1 Faculty of Archaeology, Leiden University, the Netherlands
Public participation in archaeological projects is becoming ever more essential and experimental archaeology is an excellent way of reaching out and creating a scientific community in which both the general public and archaeological scientists can learn from each other. At Masamuda near Rotterdam (Netherlands) local volunteers have established an open-air archaeological educational centre focused on the Rhine/Meuse delta. In 2016 volunteers and professional archaeologists have built a Neolithic dwelling here. In collaborative interdisciplinary research project, we attempt to fill in the details of daily life around this house: which crafts were carried out, how was food processed, and how did people move about this water-rich landscape? These questions are addressed through a combination of experimental archaeology and microwear and organic residue analysis. Discussions and practical interaction with the volunteers, each with their own knowledge and experience, have raised new questions not previously posed by archaeological scientists. These, in turn, have opened up new research avenues and alternative interpretations, to be explored through further through experiments and scientific analysis. Last, the scientific knowledge and practical expertise obtained by the volunteers is transferred to the centre’s visitors, ensuring a teaching-learning continuum outlasting the current research project.
Reconstructing the Workshop from Viborg Søndersø: New Insights into Viking Wooden Building Construction (paper)
Jim Glazzard1, Aimée Little1, Steve Ashby1
1 YEAR Centre, Department of Archaeology, University of York, UK
This paper will present the methodology and interim findings of a project that brings together experimental archaeology, artefact studies, and the social use of space.
The aim is to understand the daily experience of non-ferrous metalworkers of Viking-age Britain and Scandinavia using actualistic methods. The first task involved reconstructing a Viking-age workshop at the YEAR Centre, at the University of York.
The workshop chosen for reconstruction was excavated at Viborg Søndersø, Denmark, in 2001. While this initially seemed to be a straightforward task, with the 3 by 5 metre building being an ideal size for a reconstructed workshop, the idiosyncrasies of the original building have resulted in new insights into Viking age wooden building construction.
Lessons learned from the construction process have provided a better understanding of the original building: giving insights into the most likely methods used, including the identification of specific challenges likely faced by the original builders. These, in turn, have implications for the interpretation of the building, the methods used to build it, and the status of the artisans who worked there.
The result is that this workshop, which has been characterised as a “primitive hut” from the excavated remains, emerges as a deliberately sited, carefully built structure, well suited to the work carried out inside. The idiosyncrasies of the structure can then be explained in terms of the building methods, and materials used.
Stypsis, Wine and Resin – Technology of Scented Oil Production from Bronze Age Aegean and Beyond (paper)
Katarzyna Gromek1
1 Independent Researcher, USA
The key step in preparation of fragrant oils was pretreatment of carrier oil with ingredients like coriander seeds (Coriandrum sativum) or sweet flag (Acorus calamus) in presence of gentle heat and wine or water. This process, called stypsis, was described as necessary to prepare carrier oil for acceptance of final aromatics, to extend its shelf life and to make the product astringent.
While the first detailed description of stypsis in the Mediterranean region comes from fourth century BC text of Theophrastus, we have earlier insights from Linear B tablets from Late Helladic III period which recorded basic ingredients used in perfumery. Wine and resin were among the ingredients mentioned, which suggest that manufacturing of scented oils and wine was related.
Wines of Bronze Age were often resinated, where resins from Pistacia terebinthus or Pinus halepensis were added as preservatives. Resinated wine mixed with the carrier oil during the stypsis was a transient ingredient, which was carefully removed by evaporation or decanting to prevent oil from becoming rancid. The chemicals from resins may have been transferred to the final product and eventually served as fixatives.
I have evaluated multiple combinations of ingredients used in preparation of carrier oil (presence or absence of wine, resinated or without resin) to evaluate both resistance to spoilage and the maturation process which has been ongoing for nearly four years.
Though analysis of surviving samples of scented oils has not detected any wine degradation products so far, my work on carrier oil processing clearly indicates that the quality and shelf life of the final products is best preserved by using resinated wine during stypsis.
Experimental Beadmaking with Roman Glass (paper)
Sue Heaser1
1 Glass Bead Archaeology Studio, Suffolk, UK
My research on Early Medieval glass beads from Britain and Europe involves replicating ancient monochrome and polychrome beads to identify the making and decorating techniques. I use only replica tools and a heat source of similar temperatures to the likely furnaces used then. This has led to a greater understanding of the techniques of ancient beadmakers which has fine-tuned bead categories and identified beads that were probably made by single individuals or those from one workshop.
I used modern soda-lime beadmakers’ glass from Murano that has similar chemical constituents to ancient glasses as shown from XRF and other analyses. But it was important to be sure that this glass behaved in a similar way in the flame to the ancient glasses. I needed to study the physical properties of the ancient glass, its melting point, working temperature range and behaviour in the flame.
Roman glass was widely used for beadmaking in early medieval times, so I approached the Museum of London. They kindly supplied me with a quantity of Roman cullet (waste glass) to experiment on. My presentation will show the results of my experiments with videos of replica beadmaking, and photographs of beads made from Roman glass, compared with excavated beads of the period. My tests show that Roman glass behaves almost identically in the flame to the modern soda-lime glass which proves that the techniques I have discovered are valid. I will also show the results from colouring Roman glass with the same metallic oxides found in ancient glass to create colourful polychrome replica beads.
Was It Always Leather? (paper)
Sally Herriett1
1 University of Plymouth, UK
Understanding environmental nuances which enable preservation of organic materials can sometimes be complicated. However, this results in distinct environments conserving specific materials. Across northern Europe, peat bog environments have enabled a variety of artefacts to be preserved, and while perhaps the most dramatic is the human remains, there is also a variety of other skin-based artefacts. While it is commonly accepted that these human remains have had no preservational processing prior to their deposition and are not referred to as ‘leather’ men, the same cannot be said for all skin artefacts. Consequently, clothing, shoes and even the Clonbrin shield have habitually been referred to as ‘being made of leather’.
This paper will present an experimental study that explored prehistoric skin processing and peat-bog deposition. To determine if variations in skin-based materials could be noted before and after deposition in a bog environment, and to consider the question ‘are all skin-based artefacts recovered from peat bogs leather at deposition’.
Cow and deerskin were processed to make different materials, once processed, they were investigated microscopically to view the material’s structure. Next, in order to determine if any change in the materials occurred during deposition, samples were placed in a peat bog in west Penwith. Two sets were recovered after six months, with the remaining sets recovered seven months later, and all were re-examined.
By processing a variety of plausible prehistoric skin-based materials and observing them pre- and post-deposition a better understanding of the bogs’ influence has become apparent. This has enhanced the understanding of prehistoric skin-based materials and associated artefacts. Importantly it has strengthened the prospect that not all skin-based artefacts recovered from bog environments were necessarily originally made of leather, and thus, discussion of this classification needs to be reconsidered.
Is it Worth Curating? Production, Use and Maintenance of the Neolithic Metabasite-Made Macrolithic Tools (paper)
Bernadeta Kufel-Diakowska1, Marcin Chłoń1, Michał Borowski2, Radomir Tichý3, Karel Kučírek4, Martin Drahorád4, Aleš Panáček4
1 University of Wrocław, Poland
2 Independent Researcher, Poland
3 Department of Archaeology, University of Hradec Králové, Czech Republic
4 Archeopark of Prehistory Všestary, Czech Republic
For the early farming societies macrolithic tools were essential part of the equipment used in day-to-day activities, such as agricultural practices, food preparation, construction works and making craft. Among the wide range of rock types, metabasites from the Bohemian Massif played a dominant role as a raw material for tool's production in the Linear Pottery culture (LBK). It was used for making ground stone tools with a cutting edge. The high value of metabasite-made tools is evidenced by frequent finds from the Central European LBK contexts located at a great distance from the outcrops. However, the organization of the technological process, function and maintain of tools is poorly recognised. In our study we focus on the life cycle of the metabasite-made tools, that includes manufacturing, distribution, type of activities performed, methods of hafting, tool's modifications, and repairs. We present results of the microscopic observations of 70 objects from the LBK sites in SW Poland (Strzelin 16, Skoroszowice 1 and Strachów 2/2a). The group of analysed tools includes shoe-last adzes, axes, hoes, chisels and handstones modified from adzes. Experimental works provided the reference collection for the interpretation of use-wear and production traces observed on the Neolithic tools.
Studies are supported by the National Science Centre (NCN), Poland, decision No: 2020/38/E/HS3/00285.
Exploring Rock Art Application Techniques: An Experimental Approach To Study Rock Paintings from La Candelaria (Catamarca, Argentina) (paper)
Matías Landino1,2, Eugenia Ahets Etcheberry1,2, Lucas Gheco1,3, Marcos R. Gastaldi4, Marcos Tascon1,5, Marcos Quesada3, Fernando Marte1
1 Centro de Investigaciones sobre Patrimonios y Ambiente, Escuela de Arte y Patrimonio y Escuela de Hábitat y Sostenibilidad, Universidad Nacional de San Martín (UNSAM), Buenos Aires, Argentina
2 Consejo Nacional de Investigaciones Científicas y Técnicas (CONICET), Argentina
3 Instituto Regional de Estudios Socioculturales (CONICET-UNCA), Catamarca, Argentina
4 Instituto de Antropología de Córdoba, CONICET, Córdoba, Argentina
5 Escuela de Hábitat y Sostenibilidad, UNSAM, CONICET, Argentina
Experimental archaeology has proved to be an outstanding approach for studying rock art technology. In this sense, experimental programs can shed light to the macroscopic survey of application techniques through identifying material traces left during painting execution. Despite their relevance for enlightening the constitutive interactions between beings, materials, times and spaces established during making rock paintings, the application techniques usually remain unknown. This is the case of the paintings discovered at La Candelaria cave, in El Alto-Ancasti Mountain (Catamarca, Argentina). Aiming to contribute to this problem, this presentation reports an experimental approach to four application techniques (with a finger, with a swab, with a hair paint brush and with a wooden stick) in order to detect the material traces left by each one. The experiments were performed with three kind of binders and one pigment (gypsum). Then, the obtained data were used to advance in the macroscopic recording of the rock paintings of La Candelaria, allowing the identification of its different application techniques. Finally, this work highlights the importance of feedbacking rock art in situ surveys with experimental programs.
Impact of High Temperatures on Macroscopic Features of Prehistoric Pottery (paper)
Jan Ledwoń1
1 Doctoral School in the Humanities, Jagiellonian University in Kraków, Poland
Fires have accompanied man since the dawn of time, especially in the context of the use of settlements built of wood. Paradoxically, their destructive power often gives archaeologists the opportunity to better look at the past of a given community and allow us to capture a "petrified" image of the past. Thanks to this, among the strata formed over several hundred years, we can recognize traces of events taking place within several dozen dramatic minutes in the life of the inhabitants.
However, there are situations in which the characteristic fire layers are not able to survive to our times, because of natural post-deposition processes or human activities. A certain way to detect the presence of fire may be the analysis of frequently occurring categories of artefacts, which were also affected by high temperatures.
While research on the effect of fire on the transformation of bones and flints is quite well developed, there is a lack of such studies in the context of ceramics. To delve deeper into this topic, I conducted experimental research in which previously documented pottery fragments were divided into four parts and exposed to several different conditions of secondary burning. These conditions were to correspond to those prevailing in individual parts of the building during the fire and were separated based on a previous review of the literature. I then compared the fragments from the same vessels and documented macroscopic changes. Tendencies observed in this experiment are ultimately intended to develop in a new method of estimating the temperature affecting artefacts, and in the future will be confronted with results of specialized physicochemical methods.
Rediscovering the Process of Making Type 2 & Type 3 Aiglets (paper)
Gerald A. Livings1
1 Bench jeweler & Independent researcher, USA
While substantial progress has been achieved in the research of clothing, textiles, and associated items over the last century, it is still the case that the body of research on the manufacturing, use, and impact on the material culture of aiglets remains rather impoverished. Despite their nearly ubiquitous presence in clothing from the 8th century on, little to nothing is known about their actual manufacture and their impact on the material culture of the societies they are found in.
Aiglets are items that are in some way used to finish the end of laces (such as shoelaces), thongs, or cords. They function to protect the cord from unraveling, easing passage through an eyelet of some sort, or adding weight to the cord.
While it is generally understood how type 1 aiglets were manufactured, the manufacturing process for type 2 and type 3 aiglets is not well understood.
In this 15-minute slide show, I will attempt to demonstrate some conjectured processes that may be used to manufacture type 2 and type 3 aiglets. I will also attempt to provide documentation that supports my hypothesises.
I am taking a little-studied and obscure subject and making it into an informative topic that will be educational and interesting. Presented conversationally, this presentation will be of interest to the general public as well as those who study the history of how items are made.
Youth Science. NCU Students’ Achievements in the Field of Experimental Archaeology (poster
Zuzanna Majbrodzka1, Kacper Baranowski1, Anna Rauchfleisz1, Maria Skudlarska1, Maciej Urban1, Klaudia Wernerowicz1
1 Institute of Archaeology, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland
The poster presents some of the scientific projects, students conducted during experimental archaeology courses at the Institute of Archaeology at Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń. We aim to show how these experimental works could verify some of the results already existing in the literature, such as rock paintings with hand motifs (can we distinguish between those made by females and males) and boiling food in raw hides (is it not possible as was described in the older literature). Another possibility of the experiments was to shine a new light on the preparation of some specific artefacts, as in the ornamented antler arrowheads from Grzybowo. Did they require some mastered skills to create them, or was it relatively straightforward? The last example is the experiment of using different vegetable dyes on natural fabrics (wool and linen) inspired by various archaeological finds. Students tested how effective they were and how to dye the materials properly.
The overall objective of the poster was to show that youth science can be valuable, and that even relatively simple projects can broaden our views on some issues in archaeology.
Not just for food: processing Unio sp. shells at the Gumelnița communities (mill. V BC) (paper)
Monica Mărgărit1, Valentin Radu2
1 Valahia University of Târgoviște, Romania
2 National Museum of Romanian History, Bucharest, Romania
The importance of aquatic resources as a food source for prehistoric communities located in the proximity of major waterways has already been documented. These resources appear to have had a nutritional as well as a technological and social significance. Chalcolithic communities at the Lower Danube exploited freshwater shells of the Unio species for food and their valves for the manufacture of various artifacts. Shells of the Unio sp. processed to be made into personal adornments are discovered from several settlements of Gumelnița culture (the second half of the 5th millennium BC). These assemblages include pieces in different phases of transformation, from irregular splinters, to finished pieces in the shape of circular beads used as personal adornments. In this study, the raw material was interpreted as local, obtained as a by-product of the gathering process. In order to identify the costs invested in the manufacturing of this type of items, both in point of time and in point of effort, we have developed an experimental program, allowing us to record all the variables (raw material acquisition, technological stages, time recorded for each operation, tools used, evolution of the wear following the usage etc.). Finally, the items were put together in a bracelet, tracking the evolution of the surface wear and of the perforation, which would allow us an evaluation of the use of archaeological pieces. Our approach illustrates how experimental archaeology can contribute next to technological and use-wear analysis, to the reconstruction and understanding of the ways of life (whether economic, technological or cultural) of Gumelnița communities.
Experimenter's Body Analysis: a Transdisciplinary Approach (paper)
Thaisa Martins1
1 Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Dealing with the experimenter’s body has been a challenge for Experimental Archaeology since its consolidation as a subdiscipline. The subjectiveness of the experience of one’s body is pointed out as a major problem of this subject and, in a search for a more scientific perspective, it was indicated to try to discard the human element (body and experience) from the analysis. In the 2000’s, the Experimental Archaeology field initiated a turn to focus into a more interpretative and an immersive comparison with the past, trying to find the people behind these artifacts through experimentation. In this scenario, the issue of the experimenter’s body was placed as an interesting affair for methodological and interpretative data but remains a tricky matter to be approached. In this paper, we will present and demonstrate the concept of Artifactual Movement, a transdisciplinary approach between the Dance and the Archaeology field that we are developing in our PhD to address this query. Rooted in Marcel Mauss's idea of “Techniques of the Body '' we argue that, in an archaeological experiment we are engaging, invariably, with body techniques in order to carry out the experimentation. Using methodologies and theories from the Dance field, we propose a method to analyze the experimenter's body during an experimentation, transforming the body experience into analyzable and repeatable data. The result of the analysis will be the Artifactual Movement, a combination of body techniques that can be used to create hypotheses of ancient bodies imprinted in the materiality and accessed through Experimental Archaeology.
“Look at the Bones!” - Adding Bone in a Bloomery Iron Smelt. A Case Study of a practical experimental Test (paper)
Darrell Markewitz1
1 the Wareham Forge, Ontario, Canada
Through 2019, much was made in the popular press suggesting that during the Viking Age, exhumed human bone had been used in the chain of production from iron ore through to finished swords. Contradicting this, considerable experience with small scale direct reduction process bloomery iron smelting furnaces indicated that at least while creating the iron itself, the effect of adding bone would be minimal, if any. To establish what kind of physical traces that might remain if quantities of bone were added during smelting, in June 2020 a full furnace build and firing was undertaken with a range of animal bones added, then the resulting debris field recorded.
The concept, design and implementation of this experiment is discussed, and how limits on methods, instrumentation and analyzing results shaped the final conclusions. This discussion suggests how even a simple experiment, if carefully recorded, can add to the body of available knowledge, and may prove insightful both educators and other investigators.
The Contribution of different Generations of Experiments on understanding the Function of past Human Technologies and the Character of early Hominin Decision-making Processes (paper)
Joao Marreiros1,2,3, Ivan Calandra1, Geoff Carver1, Walter Gneinsinger1, Eduardo Paixao1,3,4, Jérôme Robitaille1, Lisa Schunk5,1
1 TraCEr, Laboratory for Traceology and Controlled Experiments at MONREPOS Archaeological Research Centre and Museum for Human Behavioural Evolution, RGZM, Germany
2 Institute for Prehistoric and Protohistoric Archeology, Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany
3 ICArEHB, Interdisciplinary Center for Archaeology and Evolution Human Behaviour
4 Institute of Archaeology, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel
5 University of Wrocław, Poland
Identifying and understanding changes in past human technologies over time is key to reconstruct the behavioural dynamics that characterized major evolutionary steps in our human ancestry. Archaeologists heavily rely on the experimental replication of past technological systems and artifacts to fully understand how technologies were produced, designed, and eventually used. During the last decades archaeological experimentation has been focusing not only on replicating past tool production and use but also the nature of artifact variability observed in the archaeological record. Apart from reconstructing the demands for such technological shifts and inferring on what they tell us about changes in human behaviour, topics such as the variability of raw materials are fundamental to identify and comprehend early decision-making processes in hominin ecological and cultural dynamics.
Recently, several researchers have debated the role of variable control on experimental design and organization. For the replication of modes of production and use of artifacts, researchers advocate the need for implementing and combining different generations of experimentation.
Our talk aims at presenting and discussing the distinctiveness and complementarity between the different generations of experiments, with emphasis on their contribution to the field of use-wear analysis. For each category of experiment, different aspects concerning their objectives, design, sample preparation protocols, variable control, and outcome are discussed.
From our perspective, experimental organization and design are important methods within use-wear studies. By discussing and introducing new categories of experiments, we highlight how different generations of experiments aim at different goals and should be combined to achieve a more comprehensive understanding of past technologies.
Breaking Through the Copper Curtain: Archaeological Experiment of Copper Ore Beneficiation and Smelting in Chalcolithic Technology (paper)
Inbar Meyerson1, Omri Yagel1, Erez Ben-Yosef1
1 Tel Aviv University, Israel
This study presents an experiment that aims to reconstruct Chalcolithic copper production in the southern Levant region (4500-3800 BCE) with a particular focus on the importance of the beneficiation stage. While previous research on ancient copper smelting has often centered on variables related to furnace design and operation, it is now recognized that the unique characteristics of individual ore bodies, including the nature of the host rock, the quantity and purity of minerals, and trace elements, can affect multiple stages of the smelting process. The beneficiation stage, which involves labor-intensive and repetitive tasks such as collecting, processing, and selecting raw materials, is often underrepresented in archaeometallurgical research and experiments.
To address this gap in knowledge, we conducted an experiment in 2020 using ore from the Timna Valley in the southern Levant and focusing specifically on the beneficiation stage. Our results demonstrate that this stage is crucial to the success of ancient metal production. The beneficiation process was carried out at various stages of the production chain using traditional methods, and we used pXRF analysis to show the increased copper values in the ore after each stage. In addition, we documented the experiment in as much detail as possible, including times, locations, weights, and images, in order to facilitate comparison with other experiments and enable replication of our results in the future.
Does Corrosion Matter? Experimental Study of the Influence of Patination on Use-Wear Traces on the Copper Alloy Metalwork (paper)
Jakub Michalik1, Kamil Nowak1
1 Institute of Archaeology, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland
In the case of the traceological method used to study copper-based metalwork, to consider the observed traces as prehistoric, they must be covered with a layer of patina. Otherwise, when the traces cut through the patina, they should be considered modern. Copper patina protects metal surfaces but also covers traces on metal artifacts to a greater or lesser extent.
Our speech aims to show the impact of patina layers on the presence of use-wear traces on the copper alloy metalwork. We want to investigate to what extent the patina reduces (or increases) the visibility of traces on bronze objects.
We made replicas of Bronze Age knives in conditions like prehistoric times. We used tin bronze for this purpose. Then we ground the objects and made intentional scratches using various tools and materials. Finally, we put artificial patinas on the objects' surfaces. We carefully documented each step of our experiment.
Thanks to the conducted research, we can answer the question of what percentage of prehistoric traces are visible under a thick layer of patina. Our experiment aims to invite a discussion on the traceological method itself. And to indicate the limitations of the method and whether it is possible to conduct reliable analyses of use-wear traces in the case of corroded copper alloy metalwork.
Experimental Archeology as a Tool for Understanding the Cultural Changes of Bone Artifacts from four Brazilian Early Holocene Sites
(poster)
Gabriela S. Mingatos1, 2, Mercedes Okumura2
1 LAPEEX. Laboratory for Evolutionary and Experimental Archaeology and Prehistory, FURG, Brazil
2 LEEH. Laboratory for Human Evolutionary Studies, USP, Brazil
This presentation aims to present results obtained with the use of experimental archeology to understand the production of bone tools from four Brazilian sites dated from the Early Holocene: Lapa do Santo (Minas Gerais state), GO-JA 01 (Goias state), Tunas (Parana State) and Garivaldino (Rio Grande do Sul state). Protocols were created for both the replication and the analysis of archaeological artifacts. Whenever possible, we used the same raw materials in the replication of artifacts (for example, polishing stones), however, in some cases we had to use similar but not identical raw materials (such as bones of sheep instead of deer, given the low availability of the later). Our results indicate different ways of producing artifacts among the studied sites, as well as changes and continuities of certain bone tools through time. The observed singularities in the manufacture of these artifacts demonstrate the presence of important cultural differences among past human groups in the Early Holocene in Brazil. Finally, our research can be the first step to propose future analyses to understand the potential uses of these bone tools, in order to help refine the current nomenclature of such artifacts.
Circle of Life: Trevisker Ware (paper)
Laura-Marie Miucci1
1 University College Dublin, Ireland
“Clay is more than a medium, but a tangible conduit into myriad societies of the Past”.
Focusing on material culture in early Bronze Age Cornwall, this study predominantly centres on pottery. While Beakers and Food Vessels were used as comparative reference points, the onus is on Trevisker Ware: a regional pottery-type. Associated with numerous contexts, it constitutes the largest prehistoric pottery-type in terms of quantifiable archaeological material recovered in Cornwall.
Cornwall is not often examined in detail in general studies of Bronze Age Britain, and thus, it is necessary to produce regional syntheses. By exploring Trevisker Ware, and its social, cultural and customary importance within the milieu of early Bronze Age Cornwall, this study looks to enrich the existing picture of prehistoric pottery.
This regional narrative was achieved through blended methodologies, where Experiential and Experimental archaeology contributed heavily to the project.
The craftsmanship of early Bronze Age Trevisker Ware was explored by recreating “replica” vessels. Detailed analyses of archaeological Trevisker Ware were used to inform characteristics of these experimental vessels, as well as experiments on fabric and form. Each stage in the production sequence was performed using actualistic methods, and assessed throughout. Subsequently, experiments on the fabric of Trevisker Ware, and its relationships with varying firing conditions were enacted.
Results from diverse methodologies show that early Bronze Age Trevisker Ware seemed to have strong connections with funerary practices in Cornwall, which was demonstrated through various studies concerning every stage in its object-biography (production, (re-)use, deposition). By doing so, it was thereby postulated that early Bronze Age Trevisker Ware was more than just a vessel for food/storage, but was of social and cultural importance, and may even have represented a regional signature in its craftsmanship.
Investigating Flint Awl Snapping in the British Mesolithic Using Integrated Methods (paper)
Andy Needham1, Jessica Bates1, Aimée Little1, Nicky Milner1, Diederik Pomstra2
1 YEAR Centre, Department of Archaeology, University of York, UK
2 Faculty of Archaeology, University of Leiden, the Netherlands
The use of flint awls during the British Mesolithic for drilling and piercing tasks is well established, but less well understood is the high rates of tool snapping evident from some of the key sites during the Early Mesolithic in this region. This paper focuses on the analysis of snap patterns from two of the largest known British Early Mesolithic awl assemblages: Star Carr (England) and Nab Head I (Wales). Using experimental archaeology, microscopic analysis (microwear, SEM) and literature-based research, three hypotheses regarding likely pathways to awl snapping are explored: i) taphonomy, ii) intentionality, and iii) use.
Taphonomy was considered via a review of published site reports to ascertain whether any identified variables might account for the breakage. Intentionally was explored via a series of awl snapping experiments (hand snapping by bending, and direct percussion with hard and soft hammers). The experimental tools generated were subsequently analysed using microwear and SEM analysis. To investigate patterns in snapping from use, experiments using different drilling techniques (bow drill, hand drill, and free hand) on varying contact materials were carried out. The experimental tools used were analysed using microwear and SEM analysis and were then compared to the archaeological tool snaps.
The results suggest that there is patterning in breakage depending on the methods used; these are visible microscopically and also macroscopically. This has significant implications for future studies exploring the relationships between people and their tools. Through experimental archaeology and microscopic analysis, it may be possible to differentiate intentional breakage, with implications for decommissioning and ending a tool’s biography, from accidental snapping from use.
All You Need is Mud: How Open-Air Museums can Champion Sustainability in the Built Environment (paper)
Caroline Nicolay1
1 Pario Gallico, UK
In August 2022 the new definition of “museum” accepted at the ICOM General conference recognised the key role museums and open-air museums now play in developing inclusivity, diversity, community engagement and, most importantly here: sustainability.
The importance of history, archaeology, and the study of life in the past to help answer very modern questions about sustainable living has been officially recognised. I strongly believe that open air museums can lead the way, especially in terms of sustainable architecture / construction.
From reconstructed buildings and experiments to modern structures for staff and visitor access, making archaeological open-air museums more sustainable themselves is key. Bringing together modern natural architecture specialists and archaeology professionals seems like the perfect place to start.
But open-air museums can do much more than make their own construction projects more sustainable: they can champion sustainable architecture by supporting natural building and heritage crafts professionals, providing safe spaces to experiment, offering teaching /learning opportunities to a wider, more diverse, audience and by showcasing both ancient and modern building techniques using local, natural, sustainable materials.
This might sound familiar to many listeners, but key connections are rarely made between museums and the modern natural building world. They can also be unbalanced and lead to misinterpretation and misinformation.
This paper will present various construction projects and experiments from the UK and France to try to define ways open air museums could develop and support sustainability in the built environment.
From Mould to Earth: Experimental and Traceological Study of Lusatian Socketed Axes (paper)
Kamil Nowak1, Albin Sokół2, Dawid Sych3
1 Institute of Archaeology, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland
2 Archaeological Museum in Biskupin, Poland
3 Scientific Association of Polish Archaeologists, Upper Silesian Branch, Poland
Socketed axes are one of the most common types of artifacts from the European Late Bronze Age. A local variant known as Lusatian socketed axes, distinguished by their characteristic ornamentation, has been the subject of our interest for many years.
For over a decade, we have been working on creating a database of traces of production and use-wear that have been found on the surfaces of artifacts from various contexts, such as graves, hoards, and settlements. Recorded traces are diverse and correlate with patterns observed by other scholars. The influence that conservation has on the preservation of traces of production and use-wear has also been a focus of our research.
To better understand and interpret recorded traces of production and use-wear, we have conducted a series of experiments with replicas of Lusatian socketed axes that focus on production and use. We reconstructed a workshop of a Lusatian metallurgist and made metal tools based on the available source materials. By reconstructing the casting process and experimenting with the use of these axes, we have obtained a wealth of data that enables us to reconstruct the biographies of these objects, from casting to deposition.
Our research demonstrates that a comprehensive database of traces obtained from replicas are necessary for accurately interpreting the biographies of Lusatian socketed axes and understanding the factors that influenced their deposition.
Keywords: traceology, experiment, late bronze age, lusatian socketed axes
What can be Difficult in Building the Boat? The Experiments Released During the First International Camp of Experimental Archaeology, Toruń 2021 (paper)
Justyna Orłowska1, Justyna Kuriga1, Grzegorz Osipowicz1
1 Institute of Archaeology, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland
This presentation reports two main archaeological experiments that were conducted during the first International Camp of Experimental Archaeology, which took a place in August 2021 in the Golub-Dobrzyń, close to Toruń, Poland. During the two weeks of this event, its participants divided into two groups have undertaken a task to reconstruct and test two archaic boats: a dugout and a leather-covered boat known more from ethnographic contexts as the so-called skin-on-frame canoe. All work carried out was performed exclusively using materials, techniques and tools known in the Stone and Bronze Ages. One of the boats build during these experiments, 4-meter-long skin-on-frame canoe will be exposed during the conference.
Traceology on Prehistoric Wooden Artefacts, is it Possible? (paper)
Grzegorz Osipowicz1 , Justyna Orłowska1, Giedrė Piličiauskienė2, Gytis Piličiauskas3
1 Institute of Archaeology, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, Poland
2 Faculty of History, Vilnius University, Lithuania
3 Archaeology Department, Lithuanian Institute of History, Lithuania
A rich and unique collection of wooden artefacts has been discovered during the excavations carried out at the complex of Subneolitic (=ceramic Mesolithic) sites in Šventoji, Lithuania (sites 1, 4, 6 and 23). Preliminary microscopic observations allowed us to identify different types of technological and possible use-wear traces on their surface. In this presentation, we will discuss the experimental program implemented to establish their origin and the traceological analyses, which have become a basis for verifying some concepts concerning the possible function of the discussed artefacts. The presentation will also discuss the adequateness of the experimental studies realized for the purposes of the traceological analysis of wooden artefacts to the reality imposed by their state of preservation. In this context, we will discuss the possibilities of the traceological analysis of prehistoric wooden artefacts coming from “wet” deposits, the materials often radically changed because of the post-deposition and conservation processes.
“Slugs” of the Itaparica Tradition, an experimental Approach of the GO-JA-01 Collection (paper)
José Lucas Otero Couto1, Sibele Aparecida Viana1, Edilson Teixeira1
1 Instituto Goiano de Pré-história e antropologia, Pontifícia Universidade católica de Goiás, Goiânia, Brazil
The Itaparica Tradition is an archaeological culture defined mostly by the technological, geographical, and temporal persistence of a certain kind of lithic instrument known as "Slugs" or Plano-Convex. These instruments hold a particular production technology, defined by the Itaparica Technocomplex and are present in several sites across the Central Brazil area during the Pleistocene-Holocene transition. The purpose of this research is to investigate, by means of experimental archaeology, the operational chains of production and subsequent use of the lithic tools found in the archaeological site GO-JA-01, located in Serranópolis, Brazil, present in substrates dated as far back as cal.12.685 - 12.674 BP.
We created an experimental protocol based on the techno-functional analysis of 10 archaeological instruments from the site, this way we intend to create a basis for the creation of replicas, understood not only as the final product, but the entire chain of gestures and decision-making involved in its production, thus contributing to the replicability of the experiment and relevance of the replicas. We undertook an experimental process, which involved collecting similar raw material in the Serranópolis region, formatting cores (material that is absent in the archaeological record of GO-JA-01), debiting of support-flakes, façonage of the support-flakes and finally, use of the produced replicas in an activity of processing and preserving animal hide, presenting analyses, observations, and documentation of each step.
Through this experimental process we were able broaden the possibilities of interpretation about the debiting of supports necessary to manufacture these instruments and propose a viable use for them while also observing their life cycle through the process of usage.
Tarquinia’s Tablets: A Reconstruction of Tablet Weaving Patterns found on the Tomb of the Triclinium’s Left Wall (paper)
Richard Joseph Palmer1
1 University of Kentucky, USA
The revival of tablet weaving and its study has been primarily focused on Northern European designs from the Iron Age to the medieval period. These designs are very impressive and include opulence such as wide weaves using dozens of tablets, dizzying patterns, and inclusions of gold thread and silk. Iron Age Northern Italian and Mediterranean tablet weaves were used in many of the same applications as their Northern European counterparts, but less archaeology has been done on the tablet weaves originating from these areas. The designs for these patterns primarily survive in the art and architecture of the Mediterranean. This experiment takes the surviving art, depicting clothing from the Tomb of the Triclinium in Tarquinia, and reconstructs both the patterns and the tablets depicted. The few surviving tablet woven fragments from Etruria will help fill in the gaps of knowledge, alongside other textile studies from the Mediterranean and Northern Europe. This starts with spinning thread on spindle whorls, recreating the proper thread width, and ends with finished tablet weaves and published patterns. In reconstructing these few patterns and tablets, the door can be opened for more Etruscan and Classical study and tablet weaving reconstructions to join the well-developed experimental archaeology of Northern European textiles.
The Investigation of Recent Reconstruction of Black and Red Figure Lekythoi for Restoration Purposes Through X-Ray and X-Ray Fluorescence Spectroscopy. Ethical Restoration Practice or Not? (paper)
A.P. Panagopoulou1,2, A. Mandaliou3, G. Rousouneli3, M. Roggenbucke4
1 Faculty of Archaeology, University of Leiden, The Netherlands
2 Institute of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology “Demokritos” National Center for Scientific Research, Athens, Greece
3 Freelancer Conservator of Antiquities and Works of art, Athens, Greece
4 Museum of Archaeology and History of Art, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens, Greece
This study presents the investigation of eleven archaeological lekythoi reconstruction for restoration purposes during the previous decades through the X-Ray and X-Ray Fluorescence Spectroscopy (pXRF). The under-study artifacts come from a collection of 903 archaeological artifacts, dating from the Early Bronze Age to the Byzantine era, generously donated, in 2019, to the Museum of Archaeology and History of Art, by Eleni Martinou. More specifically, the under-study pottery was Black and Red figure lekythoi that were dated in the Classical period.
The aim of this study was mainly to highlight the contribution of the X-RAY and pXRF for identifying the recent reconstruction methods and specifically the additions of modern materials as gap-fills to the archaeological materials to investigate if these methods follow the international regulations of conservation practices and ethics.
Most of the reconstruction treatments found on the artifacts reflect extended interventive approaches that were applied by non-professionals in the previous decades. Specifically, unfired clay parts, plasters, polymeric materials, fragments from other similar ceramics that were joined to lekythos, metal wires and the artificial patina formation onto added parts indicate attempts to achieve an ideal state. The combination of new technologies (X-Ray, XRF) allowed us to recognize and investigate the recent reconstruction applications by non-professionals and to make the most appropriate conservation decisions for the future.
Identification of Plants in Mud Building Materials. An Experimental Archaeology Project (poster)
María Pastor Quiles1
1 University of Alicante, Spain
Archaeological daub gathers elements, visible both on a macroscopic and microscopic level, studied by many different disciplines: from geology and chemistry to botany. Among the imprints that may be observed with the naked eye in these earthen architectural remains, the ones corresponding to plant materials are prominent in most cases. But characterising in detail and interpreting these vegetal imprints of now lost plant remains can be difficult and also requires specialised expertise. The non-archaeobotanist, when studying daub, may do not know where to start searching for possible elements that match her/his hypothesis of which plant material was used in combination with mud, even ending in a fruitless search of images on the Internet. To allow a much more complete and integrated study of past construction, we need to bring closer archaeobotany and daub studies, through multidisciplinary research and tools that help us in this task. And when we specialists analyse these imprints in archaeological remains and try to identify the original elements, we do that with an image that is indirect and partial, because impressions are found in architectural rubble, fragments of collapsed constructions. In addition, imprints can be badly preserved or transformed by different factors, like heat or humidity. To make material studies of past earthen building more complete and more accurate and get to know better the relationship between humans and nature in the past, we are developing an experimental reference collection of plant impressions. With this project we will develop at the same time a new method, database, and tool, that scientists and society in general can consult and benefit from.
Unconventional Use of Axes: Creating a Reference Collection of Polished Stone Tools Used for Grinding Ochre (poster)
Anđa Petrović1, Diederik Pomstra1,2, Aimée Little1
1 York Experimental Archaeological Research (YEAR) Centre, Department of Archaeology, University of York, UK
2 Faculty of Archaeology, University of Leiden, the Netherlands
Results of use-wear analysis on an adze from the Holocene hunter-gatherer burial site Zvejnieki (Latvia) showed that the tool was used for an “unconventional” activity. While no wear traces were identified on the adze’s blade edge, as might be expected for this type of tool, microwear analysis revealed that the lower (flat) surface was well utilised. Traces displayed wear resulting from working animal and mineral materials, with ochre residue embedded into the surface topography. To better understand the type(s) of activity it may have been employed in, experiments were carried out at the YEAR Centre. This was necessary because no comparative published examples of similar adze use were available. Experiments were designed to replicate the archaeological wear traces. This involved eleven experiments executed with axe-like polished surfaces, ochre, additives, and different material substrates of varying hardness. One of the eleven tools showed compatible traces, enabling us to interpret a possible ritual use of the adze within the funerary context. The experiments now form the basis of a reference collection focused on grinding ochre on different organic substrates (dry, raw and tanned hide, the human body, wood) using polished stone rather than a typical unpolished grinding stone surface. Additionally, the study showed the importance of generating problem-oriented experiments in future studies - not only because of the unavailability of certain materials/traces in collections, but also because the processes in prehistory were far more complex and varied than we can imagine today.
Key words: use-wear analysis, stone tools, experimental archaeology, ochre
Late Palaeolithic Ornamentation in Experiments: A Case of an Ornamented Artefact from Birów Mountain in South Poland (paper)
Tomasz Płonka1, Marcin Diakowski1
1 Institute of Archaeology University of Wrocław, Poland
The finds of Late Palaeolithic ornamented artefacts are still very rare in Central Europe. Due to technological and experimental research we can reconstruct their life histories, first of all the way of manufacture and the technique of ornamentation. The experiments combined with microscopic research help us to find a way in which particular elements of ornamentation were produced and their sequence.
We use both methods in research of a fragment of an of an ornamented artefact found at Podzamcze, Cave IV at the Birów Mountain, south Poland. The artefact is a fragment of reindeer antler, 56.6 mm long, which is broken at both ends. Its surface is abraded and eroded by chemical and mechanical factors operating in cave deposits. Nevertheless, it is still visible the artefact is a fragment of antler blade produced by a groove and splinter technique. The ornament is composed of six rows of dots. The points are touched by erosion, but traces of their manufacture are still visible. A radiocarbon date (ca. 10,800 BP) points the artefact was made of reindeer antler dated to the transition from the Allerød to the Younger Dryas.
In experiments we used different points and different sequences of point movements to reconstruct the way of manufacture of ornamental dots. Thanks to microscopic observations and experimental works we could reconstruct a way of engraving of dots and an order in which the rows of dots were engraved. In our opinion they could be made with the same point which became blunt in the course of work.
Archaeological Experiments in the Study of the Textile Economy of the Wielbark Culture (paper)
Magdalena Przymorska-Sztuczka1
1 Archaeological Museum in Biskupin, Poland
In my research work, I focus on understanding the textile economy of the communities inhabiting the territory of today's Poland in the late Bronze Age and the Iron Age. Rarely archaeologists do have the opportunity to study both textile tools and fabrics, which were made with them. In the Late Bronze Age and Early Iron Age, the custom of cremation of the dead prevailed in most areas of Poland, which is why textiles from this period are rare finds. In addition, textile tools are mainly found in settlements. The situation changes in the Roman period. Part of the Polish lands in this period was inhabited by people associated with the so-called Wielbark culture. They practised both cremation and inhumation funeral rituals. It is why in the skeletal graves of representatives of the Wielbark culture fragments of fabrics and textile tools have been preserved: mainly spindle whorls and needles, but also the remains of the spindles themselves in the form of the so-called hooked pins with wooden residue of the shaft. Receiving research funding from the National Science Center (grant no. 2021/40/C/HS3/00121) made it possible to conduct comprehensive analyzes of textiles and textile tools from three cemeteries of the Wielbark culture population from Czarnówko, Lubowidz and Wilkowo. As part of the research, a number of experimental works were carried out, e.g. in the field of spinning and dyeing fabrics. This made it possible to compare the parameters and quality of the threads used in the archaeological fabrics discovered in these three necropolises with the yarn obtained during experiments with copies of spindles from the same sites.
Lithics From the Neolithic Shell-Bead Workshops from The Near East - an Experimental Approach (paper)
Katarzyna Pyżewicz1, Marcin Białowarczuk1, Witold Grużdź2, Michał Przeździecki1
1 Faculty of Archaeology, University of Warsaw, Poland
2 State Archaeological Museum, Warsaw, Poland
We would like to present selected issues related to the manufacture of shell beads among Neolithic societies from the Near East. We based our studies on materials from Bahra 1 site located in north Kuwait. During our studies, we applied a combination of experimental and use-wear analysis. We investigated the individual steps of the chaîne opératoires of the shell bead manufacturing, mainly in the context of production and usage of lithic tools. During the experiments, firstly, we focused on a specific way of production of micro-bores associated with the splintered technique. The second part of our experimental tests was related to the use of lithic tools during the shell beads forming. The third part was related to use-wear analysis - we compared the results of the microscopic analysis of experimental tools and beads with artifacts from Bahra. As a result of studies, we identified several phases of the chaîne opératoires for bead production in the context of Neolithic assemblages from the Near East.
Teeth, Fibre-Crafts, and Health: What Experimental Archaeology can tell us about the Textile Workers of the Ancient World (paper)
Anita Radini1
1 University College Dublin, Ireland
The production of textiles is one of the most important activities in human history. Textile workers in the past (and in modern times) could experience very unhealthy working conditions with serious impact on their physical wellbeing. Microscopic remains of fibres such as cotton, bast fibres and wool have been retrieved from an unusual deposit on ancient human teeth: dental calculus.
Dental calculus, also known as tartar, consists of mineralised dental plaque (a biofilm formed on teeth by bacterial activity in the oral cavity). During its formation, dental calculus can entrap in its matrix a wider range of materials, including fibres and microscopic parts of dye plants.
Evidence of fibres in the dental calculus matrix is widespread across different periods in human history and diverse geographic locations but it is difficult to interpret. This paper discusses the use of experimental archaeology in addressing the topic of textile fibres in ancient human dental calculus. It aims to assess to which extent such remains can be used, in combination with other archaeological parameters, to track the textile workers of the ancient world from their skeletal remains and how such work may have affected their health.
Turning Roman Columns on the Lathe: Experimental Approach and Archaeological Analysis of Artefacts from North-Eastern Gaul (paper)
Nicolas Revert1 & Brice Brigaud2
1 RMA Roman Archaeology, Lille University, France
2 RMA Archaeology of Roman Construction, Besançon University, France
Many buildings and quarries throughout the roman empire display elements of columns that bear unmistakable hints of them having been turned on a lathe: small accidental concentric grooves and ridges as well as specific types of mortises on one or both extremities. No iconography or written source may help us reconstruct such a machine.
Therefore, experimental lathes – vertical or horizontal – have been proposed in the last twenty years, first of all in the Saintonge region, where a roman turning workshop was identified. The vertical lathe that was created by the Fabri Tignvarii was entirely built out of wood and was used to turn seven column drums in a relatively soft limestone. For the first time, this process was carried out in the context of an experimental building worksite. After the unavoidable manual hewing that takes several hours, the turning process can achieve a satisfactory cylindrical
drum in less than an hour. This experiment highlights the importance of the hewing technique, as well as the minute details of a proper mortise. The difficulties faced during experimentation were the same in ancient times. Indeed, lapidary traces on stone artefacts analysed in the Lorraine region of North-Eastern France show minor defects that hint at the partial failure of the process. Nonetheless, the proportion of column elements that were turned on the lathe is extremely high, sometimes systematic. Far from a marginal activity, stone turning contributed to the democratisation of stone architecture, in urban contexts as well as the countryside.
Belting Up; Building Technical Literacies in the History of Technology Through Experimental Archaeology (paper)
Michael Roberts1
1 York University, Toronto, Canada
While graduate history programmes usually require language literacies, technical literacies are not seen as necessary or teachable skills, and most programmes lack both facilities and methods to help researchers develop them. Outside the academy, however, there are extensive resources for learning the skills, habits, and sensitivities associated with the technology of the past. In this paper, I argue that neither archives nor artifactual remains can be fully interpreted without access to the tacit, sensory, and procedural knowledge historical actors took for granted, and that to achieve this access, academic historians must widen their understanding of how historical research is conducted.
Referencing the work of William Marshall (1745-1818), as well as more familiar works on participant observation, I offer one potential strategy for formalizing knowledge gained through experiential methods. I will illustrate the benefits of this type of work through my own readings of rural engineer’s diaries conducted in the context of extensive experiential work which I began prior to returning to academic study. Some of this work has been conducted within a continuous teaching tradition that reaches back to the historical actors I study, and some is the product of reconstruction; I will present some preliminary notes on the advantages and draw-backs of these different methods.
Technical literacies are as important to the study of the past as language skills, but they have been undervalued within the academy. This paper contributes to a growing effort to include and learn from scholars outside the university tradition, and to recognize that “other” ways of knowing are crucial to a full understanding of the past.
Can we identify handedness on the Gönnersdorf plaquettes? An experimental approach on the lateralisation of Upper Palaeolithic engravers (poster)
Jérôme Robitaille1 & Lisa-Elen Meyering2
1 Monrepos, RGZM, Neuwied, Germany
2 Durham University, UK
This poster will detail the mechanisms of engraving, in particular our attempt to understand lateralisation, on the 16.000-year-old Gönnersdorf plaquettes featuring Upper Palaeolithic artistic marks. To understand the technical gestures of any engraver, it is essential to gain insights into the exact tasks that were carried out, i.e. the functional principles to satisfy a specific goal. To infer prehistoric behaviour and in particular artistic lateralisation from the archaeological record, it is necessary for us to identify how a line is drawn, i.e. engraved. The latter implies an established relationship between the engraver’s body, the direction of the engraved line, the engraver’s tool and the plaquette itself. We will present a series of experiments to analyse usewear and signs of manipulation on the Gönnersdorf plaquettes and propose a model specifying the technical modes an actor must perform under various conditions (e.g. constraints arising from uneven material). The results are then compared to the real archaeological plaquettes through microscopic 3D imaging.
Disentangling the complexity of the Gönnersdorf plaquette engravings: manual and robotic experiments (paper)
Jérôme Robitaille1 & Lisa-Elen Meyering2
1 Monrepos, RGZM, Neuwied, Germany
2 Durham University, UK
Engraving on portable materials has a long tradition within the records of the Upper Palaeolithic. Traces of usewear and striations on engraved objects have, however, been rarely studied and are thus poorly understood. The form and structure of an engraving depends on the type of tool, the engraver’s gestures and know-how and the mentality and collective imagination of their cultural group. Engravings bear a wealth of knowledge and can transport us back to key modes of decision making of the past. Even apparent simplicity entails a plethora of technical information. The enduring traces provide clues to prehistoric kinesics within time and space, often revealing information on the overall disposition and intention of the engravers themselves.
Through manual as well as robotic experimentation, we will shed light on the way artists engraved the Gönnersdorf plaquettes, 16.000-year-old schist slabs featuring Upper Palaeolithic artistic marks. We will be able to share information on the laterality of the artists; the succession of the engravings; the extent of reuse of the plaquettes and the fact that, in some cases, different artists engraved on a single plaquette. To conclude our findings, we will even be able to reveal whether certain kinds of artistic details might have been unique to certain engravers, akin to personalised handwriting from the past.
Hands-On History: Teaching Experimental Archaeology in a School Setting (paper)
Nathalie Roy1
1 Glasgow Middle School, Baton Rouge, Louisiana, USA
My Roman Technology students recreate the products and processes of ancient Roman daily life through experimental archaeology. Each class is a hands-on history lab in which young teens (ages 10-14) learn about the ancient classical world by experiencing it first-hand. They have recreated the makeup recipes of Ovid and the hairstyles of marble statues, cooked biscuits based on the recipes of Cato the Elder, built brick kilns to fire pottery, crushed oak galls to make ink, etc. The class is a unique experience, but it doesn’t happen by magic. Planning and executing each unit of study is a complicated and time-consuming process.
In this paper session, I will talk about the specifics of the class and explain how I teach experimental archaeology to young students in practical terms. Specifically, I will discuss two large-scale projects to illustrate my process. In the first, creating a twenty-foot analemmatic mosaic sundial, students learned to cut stone tesserae and design and lay out a Roman-style mosaic. In the second, students built a full-scale Roman road through an open space on our campus. Through a series of ten steps, I will detail how I researched, planned activities, organized supplies, delegated work, reached out to experts, and taught the lessons all while giving the students the best experience possible.
Manual Vs. Mechanised Experiments – Evaluating the Effect of Human Variability on Tool Performance and Use-Wear Formation (paper)
Lisa Schunk1,2, Ivan Calandra2, Walter Gneisinger2, João Marreiros2,3
1 University of Wrocław, Poland
2 TraCEr. MONREPOS, LEIZA, Neuwied, Germany
3 ICArEHB, University of Algarve, Faro, Portugal
The interpretation of past human lithic technologies is highly dependent on the understanding of tool function and use. Experiments are fundamental to assess tool function and to build a reference collection. Besides that, use-wear analysis allows for an identification of potential use activities.
Traditionally, experiments are performed manually; often to test initial interpretations or broader correlations. In contrast, mechanised, highly controlled experiments can test individual factors independently to identify diagnostic patterns. While manually conducted experiments may impact the interpretation of the archaeological record directly, mechanised experiments usually do not. To bridge both types, a comprehensive tri-parted experimental workflow was designed. Different, but complementary types of experiments were performed: highly controlled experiments (material tester), controlled experiments with human-like variation (robotic arm) and manual experiments. The overarching aim was to test whether the previously detected causal, mechanical relationships are still relevant when human variability is included.
For all experiments, a defined number of cutting strokes of a given length were performed with standardised flint samples on artificial bone plates. Force, speed, and acceleration were controlled in both mechanised experiments.
The applied experimental trajectory allows for a comparison of tool performance. The developed use-wear on the samples was analysed for differences.
This methodological approach highlights the importance of both mechanised as well as manual experiments to understand cause-effect relationships between individual variables and the formation of use-wear, within a larger framework of archaeological questions. The incorporation of “human” variability via the robotic arm demonstrates that the gap between both extremes of experiments can be filled reliably.
Experiments to Elucidate Cooking Methods Using Reconstructed Pottery (paper)
Tetsuya Shiroishi1, Hashiguchi Yutaka2
1 Yamagata University, Yamagata, Japan
2 Yokohama History Museum, Yokohama, Japan
This study examines how pottery was used for cooking using reconstructed Japanese pottery from the Yayoi Period (about 2,800 to 1,800 years ago). The Yayoi period was the first time rice was produced in Japan. Previously, the pottery used for cooking in the Jomon period, which was primarily a hunter-gatherer period, was a long-bodied pot. However, when rice began to be cooked in the Yayoi period, a morphological change occurred to pot-shaped pots. In addition, use marks of soot and scorch marks on pottery indicate that pots of the Yayoi period were strongly heated in the lower part of the body and the interior was scorched, pointing to the high possibility that the hot-water method of cooking rice, one of the methods used today in Southeast Asia and other areas of the world, was used.
However, the Japanese archipelago is long from north to south, and the forms of pottery vary widely from region to region. Therefore, the above-mentioned point cannot be generalized. Lipid analysis and carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios for the charred pottery interior, which was also analysed for cooking contents, revealed that not only rice but also a mixture of cereals, fish, and animals was used in the cooking.
Based on the results of detailed observation of use marks on Yayoi pottery excavated from the south-eastern region of the Japanese archipelago where Tokyo and other cities are located, the reporters fabricated reconstructed pottery and conducted actual cooking experiments to verify the cooking method based on the contents derived from the scientific analysis. This report describes a series of such experiments.
Reconstructing the Pyrotechnological Development of The Harappans Using Ethnographic Parallels in The Region of Ghaggar, India (paper)
Garima Singh1
1 Deccan College, Pune, Maharashtra, India
Indus Valley Civilization, also known as the Harappan Culture, flourished in India and Pakistan owing to its technological advancements. The present paper aims to trace the emergence of pyrotechnology through documenting the industrial settlements that have been excavated in recent years, as well as locating the potential trading network for the craft items being produced at these small settlements on the outskirts of major Harappan cities such as Harappa, Mohenjodaro, etc.
In the present paper, the author aims to focus on areas such as Binjor (4MSR), Tarkhanwala Dera, and Rakhigarhi in India's Ghaggar riverbed region. The reconstruction of kilns and furnaces based on the excavated remains considered through the experimental study, such as wheel motion and the quantification of fuel consumption in the production of pottery, including terracotta figurines, bead and copper objects. During her research, the author has documented more than 50 furnaces, attempting to find parallels between Harappan heat treatment and modern potters and smiths located on ancient mounds.
The ethnographic similarities between Harappans and the contemporary villagers who continue to inhabit the archaeological mound will also be emphasized. The research also examines whether the technology utilised by the Harappans has changed, ranging from pottery manufacture to copper smelting, and what can be deduced from these experimental approaches to comprehend the technological prowess of their artisans.
Z for warp, S for weft. Investigating Choices of Yarn in English Medieval Textiles (paper)
Kat Stasinska1
1 AOC Archaeology, UK
Most Medieval textiles in England (9th to 15th centuries) were woven in a specific way: with threads of weft and warp twisted into a different direction (Z-spun yarn in the warp and S-spun yarn in the weft). It differed meaningfully from the technological choices of the earlier times (83 to 87% of early Anglo-Saxon textiles were woven with warp and weft threads twisted in the same direction). The reason for this change is not clear (with some researchers suggesting aesthetic choice or a foreign influence).
My research aimed to discover the reason behind this transformation. I have woven several samples from the hand-spun fleece of a Shetland sheep (Medium type fleece, typical for late Anglo-Saxon England). I prepared 3 sets of samples: woven in 1. tabby, 2. simple twill and 3. broken diamond twill.
I compared the physical properties of textiles woven in ZZ and ZS techniques. I focused on comparing:
- Strength (measured by applying weight and checking how much weight samples can take)
- Elasticity (measured by applying a stretching force and checking for deformation)
I took under consideration an often-suggested possibility that the change in the weaving technology was a purely aesthetic choice. To investigate this option, I compared the difference in visual properties such as visibility of pattern and appearance when dyed (samples were dyed with madder, Rubia tinctorum - a dyestuff popular in Anglo-Saxon England). A poll in person was conducted to collect opinions about the appearance of samples woven in ZZ and ZS, both dyed and not dyed.
Comparative Cheesemaking: Roman and Neolithic Cheese and the Ceramic Vessels Used to Produce them (paper)
Scott D Stull1
1 Moffett Center, SUNY Cortland, USA
Cheesemaking in Europe has a history that goes back to the early Neolithic, roughly 7000 years ago, based on archaeological evidence. We also have good archaeological and documentary evidence of cheesemaking from the Roman period. Through the replication and use of the ceramic vessels from these two distinct periods, we can gain a more complete understanding of how cheese was made in the past. This study examines how the shape of the vessels has a significant impact on the type of cheese possible in these forms. Different approaches to cheese production are tested with these vessels to identify what kind of cheese works with these different vessels, and as a result, how that cheese would have been stored and consumed in these past societies. The Neolithic cheese strainer in particular required extensive experimental testing to determine how cheese could have been produced in this kind of vessel without the use of cloth lining or other elements to strain the curd, and these tests will be described in the paper.
Experimental Archaeology and Assumptions about the Products from Prehistoric Ancient Iron Smelting Sites of Northern Thailand (paper)
Yoddanai Sukkasam1
1 The Fine Arts Department, Ministry of Culture, Thailand
This paper is aimed to present a results of five years archaeometallurgical research and Experimental archaeology research in the basin of Li District Lamphun Province, Northern Thailand. To present:
- The ancient iron-smelting site from archaeological survey and excavation in Li District, Lamphun Province
- The findings from the synthesis of knowledge through experimental archaeology
The survey indicates that there are no less than 40 ancient iron smelting sites in Li District, Lamphun Province. The Ancient iron smelting sites date around 500 BC - 100 BC. The dating indicated that the group of iron smelting site in Li District, Lumphun province is the oldest iron smelting site in northern Thailand nowadays.
The archaeological excavation and evidence analysis of Li ancient iron-smelting site in Lamphun Province have revealed that the Direct Iron Smelting Process operating temperature at roughly 1,150-1,300 °C by using a shaft furnace with a diameter between 90-100 cm. The height of the furnace is between 180-200 cm. The furnace was formed by moulding a cylindrical clay. There are the slots that act as air ducts as well as observation points. In the lower part of the furnace, four slag notches that drilled in square shape.
These results lead to the study of Experimental Archaeology which indicated that the type of Li ancient iron smelting caused the turbulent flow in the furnace and finally produced a Ring-Shaped Iron Bloom. This is the unique product, and their technique is the highlight of this ancient iron smelting furnace.
The Gislinge Boat Open Source Project: from experimental archaeology to outreach (paper)
Tríona Sørensen1
1 The Viking Ship Museum in Roskilde, Denmark
The Gislinge Boat Open Source Project took place at the Viking Ship Museum from 2015-17. The idea behind the project was an entirely new one for the Museum, namely, to explore how open source approaches could be applied to experimental archaeology and boatbuilding.
With the aim of getting people involved in building their own version of the Gislinge Boat - a 7.7 m long Danish boat-find dated to ca. 1125 AD - the working drawings for the boat were made available for free download and a programme of digital dissemination communicated all aspects of the building process, providing an informal ‘how-to guide’ to building the boat.
The initial results of the project were presented at EAC 11 in 2017. This paper will provide an updated account of what has happened in the interim. It’s now over seven years since the project was formally concluded at the Museum boatyard but it continues to have a life of its own online, thanks to the digital community social media provides.
Selected case-studies of boats that have been built from as far afield as Normandy, France and Connecticut, USA, will examine the potential experimental archaeology has to reach out to, and engage with, a much wider community than the ‘traditional’ museum-going public, and how this in turn can generate new interest in experimental archaeology as a discipline. The impact the project has had on the Viking Ship Museum’s dissemination practice, and the extent to which it continues to influence our approaches to the documentation and communication of maritime experimental archaeology will also be explored, allowing an opportunity to reflect on the often-overlooked social aspects of museum outreach.
Experimental Archaeological Observation on the Base of Chinese Terracotta Xiao Flute Player Figurine (202 BC-220 AD) (paper)
Bangcheng Tang1
1 Baoding University, China
Terracotta xiao flute player figurines as burial artifacts were popular in the middle and lower reaches of the Yangtze River during the Han Dynasty (202 B.C.-220 A.D.) in China. Combing through Chinese terracotta Xiao flute player figurines from different regions of the Han dynasty, it was found that a near-round or Yushang (an ancient Chinese drinkware)-shaped base was often placed underneath the xiao flute. This base type can also be found in African wooden flute player figurines. The reconstruction experiments of the base of the figurines was carried out by simulating the performance of a real person holding a flute using the base. The sound intensity was recorded and analyzed quantitatively using a digital sound meter combined with musicological analysis methods. The experimental results show that the base of the figurine can change the sound intensity of the played piece and support the weight of the player’s arm, which helps to reduce the player’s muscle soreness. Besides, the base may hold condensation inside the xiao produced from the play, which is assumed to have specific ceremonial meanings. The experiment of reconstructing the base of the terracotta xiao player figurine is a musical archaeology experiment from the perspective of experimental archaeology. We hope our experiments and results contribute to future research about similar topics in the archaeology community.
Keywords: Chinese terracotta, xiao flute player figurines, experimental archaeology
Searching for ‘the true colors’ of the Eastern European Chalcolithic painting techniques, through experimental and archaeometrical approaches (paper)
Felix-Adrian Tencariu1, Ana Drob1, Maria-Cristina Ciobanu1
1 Universitatea Alexandru Ioan Cuza Iași, Iași, Romania
The Chalcolithic Cucuteni-Trypillia culture (~5000-3500 BCE) stands out within the Old Europe through the characteristics of its habitat (vast territory, mega-sites, housing architecture), technical achievements, spiritual and artistic manifestations, to name a few. Of these, the exquisite painted pottery has been the main focus of numerous typological, stylistic and technological (archaeometrical) studies. Although very promising, the painting techniques of the Cucuteni pottery were not sufficiently approached by experiment; the timid previous attempts were not systematic and did not generate valid premises. The archaeological data on which our experiments were based are the painted archaeological pottery; rare discoveries of tools and deposits of pigments used for painting; older and newer studies dealing with elemental analysis of paint samples throughout the Cucuteni-Trypillia civilization. The red, black and white preponderant colours derive mainly from mineral pigments comprising iron and manganese oxides, as well as various calcium compounds. At this stage we used raw oxides and calcium carbonate commercially available. These were combined with various bindings (organic and/or mineral) and applied as engobes and as paints on dozens of standardized clay plates; prior and/or after painting, various finishing techniques were applied to the clay surfaces (smoothing, burnishing). The samples were fired in an electric kiln at 900°C. Subsequently, a few selected techniques were applied on life size vessels, fired in an experimental kiln. Several samples of clay plates and experimental vessels were investigated using OM, SEM-EDX and micro-FTIR and compared with the archaeological data from which the experiments started. At the end of this stage, we have some hypotheses validated by experiment, noting that these are not necessarily the only techniques used by Cucuteni craftsmen to apply and bind the paints on their pottery.
Experimental Study of Grinding Installation (paper)
Ana Tetruashvili1, Davit Dolaberidze1, Tina Davadze2
1 Institute of Archaeology, Tbilisi State University, Georgia
2 Architect-restorer, Georgia
The present paper deals with the experimental study of the grinding installation, building an experimental model of the Grakliani Gora grinding installation and grinding grain on it.
Experimental work was divided into three stages:
- The building process of grinding installation;
- Usage of experimental grinding installation to grind the grain (wheat and barley)
- Microscopic observation.
The experimental work lasted 18 days. A man and a woman were involved in the construction. We used 400-470 kg clay for installation. 1 bundle of stubble and 70-80 pieces of cobblestone (10X10cm wide and 20X30cm long). The height of the experimental installation is 60 cm and the width is 95 cm. It exactly repeats the dimensions of the Grakliani Gora grinding installation, with the exception of the length - 157.5 cm instead of 135 cm, the increase of which was caused by the width of the querns. For basalt quern with flat working surface we choose flat or slightly concave upper stone, and the sandstone quern with a boat-shaped working surface - a one-handed or two-handed upper stone with convex working surface.
As for the grinding process, from 2 kg wheat we got:
- 550 gr. bran
- 1,400 gr. Coarsely ground flour
- 50 gr. waste
- 1,000 gr. fine flour left after grinding 1,400 gr. coarsely ground flour and 400 gr. Sifted mass.
From 2 kg Barley we received:
- 600 gr. of bran
- 1,300 gr. of coarsely ground flour
- 100 gr. waste
- After grinding 1,300 gr. Coarsely ground flour we got 900 gr. fine flour and 400 gr of sifted mass.
The project was supported by the FaRiG.
Baltic Experimental Archaeology and Ancient Technology Summer School Between Science, Education, And Tourism: Conclusions after first 10 Years (paper)
Artūrs Tomsons1,2
1 University of Latvia (Faculty of Social Sciences)
2 Society Latvijas Arheoklubs (NGO), Riga, Latvia
First results of the ancient technology and experimental archaeology project in Āraiši, Latvia started in 2013 were presented in EXARC conference in Burgos, Spain in 2014 by the author of this report. In 2023 the project celebrates its 10th anniversary. Since then, the project has gone through several changes and transformations. It has changed its formal affiliation from project which was initially supported by the National History Museum of Latvia and its former branch Āraiši archaeological park. Since 2017 project is being organized by society Latvijas Arheoklubs and I have changed its location to Riga, Lucavsala Island. Also, the main target audience of the project - mostly archaeology and anthropology students who have limited possibilities to acquire practical knowledge of working with materials used in prehistory within the limits of official study courses – has been broadened. Thus, during these years several hundred participants from the Baltic countries, Germany, Hungary, Turkey, The Netherlands, Japan, Pakistan have participated at least in one of the workshops organized by the summer school bringing closer academic knowledge to wider public.
Bone Tubes from Corded Ware Culture as Sound Generators/Musical Instruments. Reconstructing Manufacture and Usage (poster)
Dominika Tokarz1
1 University of Wrocław, Poland
This poster presents the results of an experiment on making a bone tube and testing its acoustic properties. The bone tubes that are the object of the reconstruction are associated with the Corded Ware culture. Such tubes were recorded in graves, mainly as single finds. An exception is an object from the Moravian site - Kostelec na Hané, which provided a set of bone tubes interpreted as a Pan flute. The experiment aims to answer three questions. The first question is about the manufacturing process, the time, materials, and efforts needed to prepare it according to a specific chain operation called a cognigram. The second question concerns the identification of manufacture traces on the bone tube using microscopic methods. The last question relates to the acoustic possibilities of the bone tubes. Acoustic examination includes sound testing during the preparation stages and comparison with the final product. The experiment resulted in detailed data on the bone tube manufacturing process, reference trace observations for use-wear analysis. It demonstrated the relationship between the shaping stage and the acoustic properties of the bone tube.
Technotypes Definition and Cultural Transmission (poster)
Concepción Torres Navas1
1 Dpto. Prehistoria y Arqueología. Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Spain
From its origins, lithic industry studies have been studied and defined based on the typological definition. Currently, the typological elements move away from the first merely classificatory approaches to delve into a dynamic approach in which the lithic knapping processes became an essential part of the type definition. Thus, the technotypes are not isolated units of analysis, but the result of the technical and technological recognition, the experimental replication comparison, and the technological reading on archaeological and experimental collections.
The Experimental Archaeology Laboratory (LAEX-UAM) is working on the creation of a technotype collection that collects products related to different levels of technical and technological knapping skills. It´s a repository of lithic types where irreversible errors, errors followed by solutions, final forms of high or low skill, etc. are documented and stored. Ultimately, it´s an open-access collection that tries to define knapping skills through experimental recognition for a better understanding of past human behaviour.
The Saka Barrow Building Technology: Experimenting with Turf and Logs (poster)
Ulan Umitkaliev1, Diana Ayapova1
1 L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University, Kazakhstan
Researching of architecture and construction technology of Saka period funerary monuments is one of the priority directions in Kazakhstan archaeology. At the same time, the question of using experimental archaeology methods in such study remains relevant. The architecture of the studied Baigetobe mound consisted of three building levels: an earth embankment, a stone embankment, and a wooden-stone burial tomb. During the excavation, attention was drawn to the presence of forty-centimetre layers of turf and construction layers. This article presents the field experiment results on the preparation and transportation of turf and logs with the help of horses during the year. The aim was to gain a deeper understanding of the process of building the royal barrows. In general, experimental studies of the materials used in the construction of large barrows help to take a different look at how the structure was built. Thus, data from experiments may indicate that organized collective labour was required for such large-scale structures. The scientific results of the study were published in domestic journals, here we demonstrate the course of the experiment itself.
Prehispanic woodcrafts in the Canary Islands: technical processes and experimental program (paper)
Paloma Vidal-Matutano1, Antoni Palomo2, Dorota Wojtczak1, Amelia Rodríguez3, Idaira Brito-Abrante3, Jared Carballo-Pérez4, Kiara Ortega5, Salvador Pardo-Gordó6
1 UDI de Prehistoria, Arqueología e Historia Antigua, Departamento de Geografía e Historia, Universidad de La Laguna, Spain
2 Departament de Prehistòria, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain
3 TARHA Research Group, Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain
4 BAPADNA Research Group, Departamento de Geografía e Historia, Universidad de La Laguna, Spain
5 Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria, Spain
6 GISPRAYA Research Group, Departamento de Geografía e Historia, Universidad de La Laguna, Spain
The Canary Islands offer a rich archaeobotanical heritage, including the preservation by desiccation of wooden artefacts manufactured by the aboriginal groups that arrived from North Africa during the first millennium AD. These first settlers had to adapt to the local raw material availability, which lacked metal ores and thus developed volcanic lithic technologies and woodcraft in an insular environment.
During the last year, an interdisciplinary approach based on archaeobotany, experimental archaeology and tool-mark and wear analyses has been applied to study the production and usage of wooden artefacts in this chronocultural context within the framework of the WoodTRACES project (H2020-MSCA-IF-2020; European Commission). This research line is currently being developed within the framework of new funding (Spanish Ministry of Science, PID2021-125055NA-I00).
In this oral communication we present the preliminary results from the identification of the woody raw materials exploited, the tool marks observed on the analysed wooden artefacts from several islands and its comparison with an experimental reference collection generated.
Experimental work focused on the manufacture of replicas (basalt / obsidian lithic tools and bone chisels) and the production of a reference collection of tool marks on different woods (Pinus canariensis, Salix canariensis, Myrica faya) in relation to the different actions of the woodworking process: debarking, splitting, roughing, final regularising and polishing. This experimental programme, which will continue over the next years, aims to better understand the woodworking technologies developed in the different islands, trying to distinguish possible distinct technological adaptive responses according to the biogeographical differences (plant availability) and woodworking tools/techniques.
Experimental Reproduction of Traces Documented on Middle Palaeolithic Bone Retouchers from the Ciemna Cave (paper)
Piotr Werens1, Damian Stefański1, Katarzyna Zarzecka-Szubińska2
1 Archaeological Museum in Kraków, Poland
2 Department of Paleozoology, Faculty of Biological Scientes, University of Wrocław, Poland
During the analysis of the Paleolithic osteological material from the Ciemna Cave (Valde-Nowak et al. 2014; Valde-Nowak et al. 2016), several bone tools attributed to middle Palaeolithic cultural layers and interpreted as retouchers were identified. A retoucher is a bone, tooth, or antler used in the process of making stone tools. The goal is to form the final shape or surface of the tool (the working edge, the surface used to hold the tool or set it in the holder) (e.g.: Mallye et al., 2012; Neruda, Lázničková-Galetová, 2018). Traces present on retouchers can take the form of single triangular or oval depressions, scratches in the form of lines - straight, wavy, rounded, and when the retoucher is intensively used, the traces of impacts overlap creating a damaged area on the bone (Mallye et al, 2012). The experiment aims to confirm our preliminary hypothesis. It will involve a different retouching method including a bifacial one; a different position of the retoucher, as well as interaction vectors.
Retouchers at middle paleolithic archaeological sites in Poland seem to be extremely rare. Perhaps the reason for this is the nature of the traces on their surface, which can be misleading with traces of biting (Mallye et al., 2012) or weathering (Behrensmeyer, 1978). Similar examples of retouchers used by the Neanderthal man are known e.g. from Scladina Cave in Belgium with MIS 5d-5b (Abrams et al., 2014), Saint-Marcel Cave in France with MIS 5 (Daujeard et al., 2018).
A Comparison of two Merovingian Pottery Kilns Found in Belgium. Results of the Experiment and Tool for Experimental Research (paper)
Line van Wersch1, Marie Demelenne2, Sylvie De Longueville3, Véronique Danese34
1 Université de Liège-CNRS Arscan, Belgium
2 Musée Royal de Mariemont, Belgium
3 Awap, Belgium
4 Ceram Histo group, Belgium
If the Merovingian pottery is quite well known thanks to the wares found in the graves, many grey areas remain for the organization of this craft. The kilns known for the period are so different in size and fitting that one could wonder if the potters were part of the same communities of practice.
Within the framework of the exhibition 'The World of Clovis' at the Royal Museum of Mariemont, we reconstructed two distinct types of kilns discovered recently in current Belgium: the first, from Quévy-le-Grand, with central circular pilar and the second, from Namur, with a central wall and floor. The aim was to compare the functioning of the two structures. We defined the temperatures reached, the time, energy and equipment required as well as the quantities produced. We assessed to what extent the control of these tools was similar or different. Questions related to the know-how and social organization of production could thus be addressed, such as the division of tasks and the specialization of the craftsmen who worked on these two sites.
The experiment also allowed us to use a methodological analysis sheet when preparing and evaluating these actions. This tool, designed by M. Demelenne within her doctoral research, allows to consider the research work in its various scientific, pedagogical, and ethical aspects in a structured and coherent way. The grid comprising approximately 160 criteria can be used as an observation and analysis tool but also as a memory aid when preparing an experimental activity.
Creating Red: Reproducing Opaque Red Glass from Iron Age Western and Central Europe (paper)
Rachel Wood1
1 University of California, Los Angeles, USA
Opaque red glass, a popular inclusion in copper-alloy based military gear of Late Iron Age western and central Europe, required intense practical knowledge to create. Artists needed a great deal of precision, ranging from the choice of ingredients, the quantity of each, the heat of the flames, and the length of time necessary to create a specific red color in a reducing environment. Successful creation of opaque red glass could only be achieved if the artisan had the knowledge and skills necessary to determine which moments of this chaîne opératoire would create the desired effect: a “sealing wax red” final product. In this presentation, I will focus on the skills necessary to create opaque red glass, particularly relating to the reducing atmosphere and time necessary in the fire, from an experiential and experimental standpoint, and explore the opportune moments which artisans needed to be wary of to gain the desired results for the market. I will explain the process behind my experimental reproduction of opaque red glass, which will begin in January 2023. This project is part of my dissertation and began with the initial research from previously published chemical analyses and scholarly articles on glass production in the ancient world. It is my hope that this project and presentation will shed light on the experience and patience necessary for successful production of a popular glass in the ancient world.
Physics of Bipolar Reduction: Quantitative approach to the bipolar mechanic through video motion analysis (paper)
Görkem Cenk Yeşilova1,2, Adrián Arroyo1,2, Andreu Ollé1,2, Josep Maria Vergès1,2
1 Institut Català de Paleoecologia Humana i Evolució Social (IPHES-CERCA), Tarragona, Spain
2 Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Dept. d’Història i Història de l’Art, Tarragona, Spain
Bipolar technique is a flaking activity that has deep evolutionary roots, identified within the earliest stone tool assemblages dated to 3.3 Ma. The mechanic of the bipolar phenomenon (placing an object on an anvil and modified it with a hammerstone) has also a huge spatial distribution across the world. Lithic production using this technique is not tied to a particular archaeological culture and it has also been recognized in the ethnographic record. We present new results of the Experimental Francolí Project. Previous research concentrated on testing the archaeological remains of the site of La Cansaladeta (MIS11; Tarragona, Spain) and ethnographic variants of bipolar reduction. Here, we focus on the mechanic of bipolar technique from the perspective of knappers with a different skill through video motion analysis. The experiments were recorded by two cameras and all the videos were analysed by using Tracker. Our goal is to investigate the physics of bipolar mechanic in a deeper and quantitative way, including the analysis of parameters such as velocity, time, kinetic and potential energies.
The obtained results will be used for a comparative analysis of the archaeological samples. The presence of the entirely refitted quartz pebbles from La Cansaladeta shows very specific indicators of the bipolar reduction, called orange segments. This kind of fractures appear due to the high axial compression on the raw material. Application of video motion analysis can play a key role to understand how the archaeological pebbles were flaked. Motion analysis by the video recording is used by many disciplines in terms of quantitative approaches. We use this method to investigate the fracture mechanics of archaeological samples.
Mining or Ore-Processing Bone Tools? A Case Study from Eastern Ukraine (paper)
Olga Zagorodnia1
1 The British Museum, London, UK
Bone tools are present in tool collections of mining sites over a wide area during the Bronze Age. Mostly, researchers associate them with ore mining due to contextual analysis and the typological proximity to bronze wedges. The assemblage of the sources from the Kartamysh sites in Donets Basin (eastern Ukraine) critically posed the problem of what was the purpose of bone artefacts in this field. Kartamysh archaeological area included settlements, sites for ore-sorting and processing, copper mines and open pits which were exploited during the Late Bronze Age (XVI-XIII BC). In order to verify the functions of archaeological bone tools we carried out experiments using similar replicas in a variety of operations. Traces on the artefacts were identified in comparison with experimental items associated with argillite mining and ore processing (a gravitational process). As a result, a new functional type was singled out – tools for stirring ore in gravitational process (total 399 items). They were made from ribs, scapulas, and long bones. The functional type of scoops for raking ore, made from animal scapulas and pelvic bones, was also identified.
Similar tools have also been found in the other Bronze Age mining areas in Europe – Schwaz/ Brixlegg (North Tyrol), Great Orme (Wales) and Kargaly (Urals). They could have been used to sort ore or to scrape copper sandstone to extract ore. At the same time, we were interested to note that rather peculiar wedges from tubular bones, which are numerous in the other ancient mines, were not found on the eastern Ukraine sites. The database that was compiled on deformations and wear traces is suitable for comparing sets of tools in general and their individual parameters with data from other ancient mining complexes.
Excursions
Excursion 1
Date: Wednesday, May 3, 2023 (whole day)
Muzeum Archeologiczne w Biskupinie
In the wetlands, 80 kilometres north-east of Poznań, 1933, a local school teacher, Walentin Szwajcer, discovered traces of a wooden settlement at Biskupin. The year after, the influential archaeologists Kostrzewski and Rajewski started large scale excavations. By the beginning of WWII, 2500 square metres were unearthed... Read more at the EXARC website.
Maximum number of Participants: 55
Price: 40 EUR p.p.
Excursion 2
Date: Wednesday, May 3, 2023 (whole day)
The Malbork Castle
The Order of the Teutonic Knights of St. Mary's Hospital in Jerusalem, commonly known as the Teutonic Order, was established during the Third Crusade to the Holy Land in 1190. At first, it operated as a brotherhood as hospitallers in Acre, then, after receiving its rule in 1198, the brotherhood transformed in a knightly order. In 1309 Grand Master Siegfried von Feuchtwangen moved his office to Malbork. The castle was promoted to the status of being the capital of one of the most powerful states on ... Read more at the Malbork website.
Maximum number of Participants: 55
Price: 45 EUR p.p.
Excursion 3
Date: Sunday April 30, 2023 (in the afternoon)
Guided tour Toruń
The medieval city of Toruń is on the Vistula River in north-central Poland and a UNESCO World Heritage Site. It is located halfway between the Polish capital of Warsaw and the major port city of Gdańsk. Toruń is well-connected with other Polish and European cities.
Maximum number of Participants: 35
Price: Free, but registration is required.
The Scientific Committee
Professor Dr Grzegorz Osipowicz (chair)
Nicolaus Copernicus University, Toruń (PL)
Society for Experimental Prehistoric Archaeology (SEPA)(PL)
https://exarc.net/members/ind/grzegorz-osipowicz
Dr Justyna Orłowska
Nicolaus Copernicus University, Toruń (PL)
Society for Experimental Prehistoric Archaeology (SEPA)(PL)
https://exarc.net/members/ind/justyna-orlowska
Professor Dr Linda Hurcombe
University of Exeter, Department of Archaeology (UK)
https://exarc.net/institutional-members/people-behind/linda-hurcombe
Dr Julia Heeb
Museumsdorf Düppel - Stiftung Stadtmuseum Berlin (DE)
https://exarc.net/institutional-members/people-behind/julia-heeb
Dr Roeland Paardekooper
EXARC (NL)
https://exarc.net/members/ind/roeland-paardekooper